Mill Reef Stakes Preview
With The Ed Culham TipsYou are here: Home /
Ed Culham Tips has kindly produced us an excellent preview, of today’s Mill Reef Stakes at Newbury.
As always it is an excellent read and preview of the highest quality, as we come to expect from Ed Culham Tips.
He is our resident Festival and Saturday Tipster who has been producing the profit for over a year now.
Get yourself signed up for his page:
https://tipstersempire.co.uk/subscribe/ed-culham/
Newbury – Mill Reef Stakes Preview
Dubai Duty Free Mill Reef Stakes (Group 2) (2 year olds) 6 furlongs
A competitive renewal of this race that was first contested in 1972. There are several strands of form to draw together, with eight intriguing contenders going to post. Rhythm Master and Cairn Gorm both bring high class Group One Prix Morny form to the table. Devilwala was runner up in the Gimcrack, often a good form-guide for this, while Bahrain Pride won well in Listed company at Ripon last time, another race that has contributed the winner of the Mill Reef in recent years. Line Of Departure won the sales race at Doncaster last week and is progressive. Unusually the market isn’t headed by one of those mentioned, but by the twice raced Fivethousandtoone. He is joined by fellow novice winners Alkumait and First Edition.
Trends – last 10 years
10/10 Winners have returned at odds no bigger than 4/1
8/10 Had run in Group company before
7/10 Had recorded an RPR of over 100 on their previous start
4/10 Had had no more than 2 previous runs
2/10 Had won a Group race previously
3 Had run in the Gimcrack on their previous outing, 1 in the Prix Morny at Deauville and 1 in the Champion 2 year old Listed Trophy at Ripon
Runners
Fivethousandtoone – 5/2*
Made a pleasing debut on Soft ground at Windsor when finishing runner-up. Blitzed the field next time out at Newcastle.
Was sent off 5/6f on debut but made quite heavy weather of things. They got racing a way out and while he responded willingly to fairly hard riding, he couldn’t get past Bahrain Pride. Noticeable from that run was his daisy-cutter action, so the ground is unlikely to have suited him. Looked far more at home on the all-weather most recently when making all in emphatic style to score by 4 lengths. He did have the benefit of experience with many of those rivals making their debuts, so it is unclear what he achieved in winning. The race was run 2.5 seconds faster than the other division of that novice event, and he managed a final 2 furlong time of 24.00s, suggesting it was a decent performance.
Clearly well thought of in the Balding yard this colt should be suited by the good ground at Newbury. He did look to get a bit outpaced at Windsor on debut however, and as a son of Frankel he might be vulnerable to a sharper rival at this trip. Not certain to reverse placings with Bahrain Pride. Looks like he has been priced up on reputation and the market has this wrong.
Rhythm Master – 11/4
16/1 on debut when winning at Haydock. Followed that with high class run when 3rd in the Prix Morny.
Evidently, he knew his job on debut and while a few of the more fancied runners underperformed in that contest, he laid down a fine marker with an RPR of 91. Straight into a Group One on his next start he ran a nice race when travelling well for a long time but failing to pick up quickly enough in soft ground at Deauville. He was only beaten by Royal Ascot winners Campanile and Nando Parrado that day, with Tactical, winner of the Windsor Castle and July Stakes, 2 lengths behind. The RPR he recorded of 111 there would virtually be good enough to win an average running of this race.
There’s much to like about his attitude and it’s difficult to pick holes in his chances. Has the best form in the race and should be favourite in my eyes. The only worry is that he may have been forced into giving everything in Group One company last time and might not progress on this occasion. Still he gives a lofty target to aim at.
Bahrain Pride – 7/2
Battled on to defeat Fivethousandtoone on debut and confirmed his ability with a good win in Listed class at Ripon last time.
To my eye this horse had to do more work than the runner up at Windsor on debut, as he was switched wide behind runners to race down the centre of the track some 2 furlongs out. Fivethousandtoone had a straighter go of it and had plenty of time to go past, but Bahrain Pride showed likable qualities to fend him off, running the last 2 furlongs in a time of 25.17s (soft ground). At Ripon he made seamless headway from wide on the track, taking up the running when still on the bridle. He was made to work a bit in the final stages there but had things comfortably in hand by the line. For all that was a Listed race it looked a weak event, the Gimcrack 7th, Roman Dynasty (66/1) was sent off second favourite and got with 2½ lengths of the winner.
Bahrain Pride looks an uncomplicated type, but other than his debut form (where he beat a highly regarded horse) there is not much to suggest he should be as close in the market to Rhythm Master. If the price of Fivethousandtoone is wrong, it would seem so (although to a lesser extent) is the price of this horse.
Devilwala – 8/1
Won a Haydock maiden in August before stepping up markedly on that when second in the Gimcrack at York.
Raced prominently on debut when made to fight for victory by Al Saariyah, a fair yardstick from the Crisford stable. He then looked briefly outpaced at York, but made fine headway down the nearside rail, staying on powerfully in the closing stages. The form of that race is beginning to look strong, and he beat some solid horses in Mysterysmiles and Yazaman that day, so he clearly has ability.
The Gimcrack form looks the second strongest in the field, so on that evidence he is overpriced here. His pedigree does have more stamina in it than a few in here however, so it might be he finds one or two too sharp. Should still run well.
Alkumait – 11/1
Finished a never nearer 4th on debut over course and distance. Produced an impressive turn of foot to win next time out in maiden company at Goodwood.
Green on his debut in July, the penny seemed to drop late on with him, and he swept home well under tender handling. He was only a length behind Line Of Departure despite that rival having the benefit of two runs in the book. The form of that contest has worked out well too with 4 next time out winners from 9 runs. He showed signs of significant improvement next time when cruising from the rear of the field. Only shaken up towards the finish, he recorded a final 2 furlong time of around 24.70s quite impressive considering it came off a slow pace on ground that was on the soft side of good. The second, beaten over 2 lengths, has since gone on to run 2nd and 1st in good company since.
A strong travelling son of Showcasing he has looked every bit a Group horse in waiting at Goodwood. He hasn’t been fully tested in his two starts to date, and I have a feeling a good tempo in this better race should suit him. Looks open to most improvement and can get involved.
Line Of Departure – 14/1
Most raced in the field after 6 starts. Struggled to get his head in front in maiden and novice company, although he did go close here at Newbury (when 1 length in front of Alkumait), before improving in handicap company. Has won the last three, including the Doncaster sales race most recently.
His penultimate run came at Ascot, where he galloped on relentlessly to the line to repel the challenge of Ataser a horse who has gone on to win since. His final 2 furlong time of 23.91s suggests that was a good effort off an even gallop on Good-Firm going. Won well at Doncaster most recently despite weaving around under the whip, beating Yazaman by over a length at the finish. That form looks only moderate.
Has earned a crack at Group company after three jolts of progression. On a form line through Yazaman (6th in the Gimcrack) he looks to need to find more here and while that is not impossible, others should be too progressive.
First Edition – 20/1
Green on debut when no better than 4th at Sandown. Returned to the same track and ran away with a small field to score by 6 lengths next time out.
First Edition is a small close coupled colt who showed plenty of speed last time out, running the final 2 furlongs in around 24.90s. Form wise that looks flimsy, especially given the 4/7 favourite Significantly (already beaten 5 times) lost several lengths from the stalls and was never in contention.
Both his runs to date have come over 5 furlongs, but he looked to be keeping on strongly last time so the step up to 6 could bring about improvement. Looks weakest in this field and will have to improve dramatically.
Cairn Gorm – 22/1
Three wins from four runs. Notched a novice and maiden, including over this course and distance. Then went on to win a Group Three in France. Disappointed behind Rhythm Master in Group One last time.
Won what was a weak Group Three at Deauville, running on strongly in the closing stages. He then looked keen in the Prix Morny, being brought through to challenge before fading tamely. Perhaps the soft ground didn’t help there.
Can be forgiven his latest run, but still has plenty to do to turn the form around with Rhythm Master.
*Prices correct at time of writing.
Summary
I can’t understand the market and the way things have been priced up here. Fivethousandtoone has no high-class form to speak of and has only won a middling event at Newcastle so looks far too short at the head of the betting. Bahrain Pride brings stronger claims, but again probably didn’t beat much last time out. Rhythm Master is solid and should be respected as should Devilwala after his Gimcrack second, but with several too short here and three places on offer it could pay to play an improver. ALKUMAIT could be just that after winning without coming under pressure from a good rival last time. His form from his debut also ties in with Line Of Departure, who despite being progressive himself I expect the selection to improve past. Cairn Gorm might have not had conditions to suit last time out and is a big price if excusing that effort but might not be up to winning. First Editon looks to require plenty more.
Suggestion: ALKUMAIT 1 point each way @ 11/1
Good luck.
Ed Culham
Sign Up To Ed Culham Tips and get 30% discount on any subscription
You can get 30% discount, using the code – EDCULHAM30