Seasonal Stories - November
With The Ed Culham TipsYou are here: Home /
Ed Culham Tips has produced a blog on Seasonal stories. Two weeks ago he started with October and now we move on to November. He will take us through the National Hunt Season so far, bringing us up to date leading to the Cheltenham Festival.
As Ed correctly points out, everything is always looking towards Cheltenham and people often forget to look back on things. You can learn so much from looking back in time and just reminding ourselves of certain performances, others might forget.
As always it is an excellent read and very well put together.
If you are new to Ed Culham Tips, he is our Festival and Saturday tipster. His Saturday Service is making over 30% Return On Investment since it started 18 months ago. Ed Culham Tips comes highly recommended as a Saturday Tipster to anyones Portfolio.
Seasonal Stories – November 2020
Seasonal stories returns with a whistle stop tour of some of the big stories from November, including gambles, gaffes, and a bit of good old headgear.
A rivalry begins
After the immediate shock of Paisley Park’s defeat in the 2020 Stayers’ Hurdle came the nagging worry – after post-race signs of an irregular heartbeat came to light – that this might be the end of the road for the dual Grade One winner.
The acid test of his well-being and ability came on his return at Newbury (Nov 27), in what had the makings of the race of the season so far. In opposition were the unlucky Albert Bartlett fourth Thyme Hill and the highly touted McFabulous.
In a steadily run race, Paisley Park got a touch outpaced off the home turn, but any doubts about his well-being were extinguished by the sight of his finishing effort as he stayed on stylishly into second after jumping the last. He met one too good however, and this marked the day Philip Hobbs’s Thyme Hill announced his arrival on the big stage. A small horse for a stayer, but one with all the girt and battling qualities of a true champion, Thyme Hill has everything required to make this division his own.
After the race Philip Hobbs said, “you wouldn’t come to a race like this half-cooked,” a comment that seemed as much a nod to the acclaim that Paisley Park is held in as a statement of Thyme Hill’s readiness for the contest.
I am sure most people would have been cheering on Paisley Park at Newbury, I almost was even before my tip McFabulous cried enough before the last hurdle. Thyme Hill too has a growing band of fans, which will only have been increased after this win. Hopefully we can look forward to many more clashes between these two redoubtable stayers.
Mix ups
Horse racing is a sport of fine margins but sometimes inaccuracy and miscommunication get the better of the argument.
If the legendary photo-finish punter Alex Bird were around today he would have been rubbing his hands by the winning line as a driving finish between Elle Est Belle and Ishkara Lady concluded the Cheltenham card (Nov 14).
In a race run in growing gloom, Ishkara Lady and Elle Est Belle came through to take up the running inside the final furlong. Halfway up the hill the Dan Skelton trained Elle Est Belle held a neck advantage, with Harry Fry’s Ishkara Lady grinding away at that lead hoof beat by hoof beat under a typically dogged Sean Bowen ride. Just as the line loomed Ishkara Lady against the rail looked to have lunged ahead only for her rival to lunge back and them to flash past together, too close to call. A photo finish.
In the time of Alex Bird, a print would have had to have been developed and then rushed up to the judge, allowing for plenty of time for a market to form on the result. We live in different times, but technology is not infallible and here the decision seemed to take an eternity in the dark. Light was the problem as it was judged from looking at the photo, a shot where the horses are only just visible against the background grey, that Ishkara Lady and Elle Est Belle could not be distinguished – a dead heat was called. To my eyes, Elle Est Belle, on the far side, would need to have grown an unnaturally long nose to be touching the line at the same time, but after all these are grey areas.
Just the following day (Nov 15) at Fontwell, seven jockeys were in hot water after their decision to by-pass the third last flight of hurdles. While we have all seen cases of riders mistaking the winning post and of riding a finish a circuit too early this was probably a case where the riders involved were not entirely at fault.
Bluebell Sally had unfortunately gone wrong on the first circuit after jumping the fourth hurdle, where she was being treated as the field approached on their second circuit. Grounds staff were seen rushing onto the course behind the hurdle with markers indicating that the field should keep wide of the stricken horse. Seven runners quickly swerved to miss out the hurdle, while Dharma Rain, who looked to beginning to tail off at the time hopped over under Jack Tudor.
The commentator quickly clarified the confusion saying: “The jockeys did not know what they were meant to do there…now I believe they had to take that flight, so we may only have one horse left in this race.”
The race continued, with Just Henny prevailing, but it was Dharma Rain who trailed in in seventh place that was awarded the race, after being the only runner to complete the course. Quick thinking by Jack Tudor, who said afterwards, “I went with my gut instinct and jumped it – but it was very unclear”.
Success stories
Continuing the theme of horses from small yards producing fine performances, a junior bumper at Huntingdon (Nov 10) provided plenty to be excited about.
Pam Sly’s has made a habit of finding fillies that are above average, most notably with the smart Speciosa, winner of the 1000 Guineas in 2006. Here she fielded the 28/1 chance Eileendover, herself a granddaughter of the great mare.
Ridden by Paul O’Brien, even early on down the back straight it was evident that Eileendover was a cut above her opposition as she made an effortless move around the outside of the field to take up the running off the home turn. With her rivals toiling in behind she went further clear hard on the bridle to take this by 28 lengths. Earning an RPR of 127 for that effort, she immediately established herself as a key player in bumpers this season, with the prospect of plenty more to come.
Across the Irish Sea, Ronan McNally continues to do well with few horses. I remember seeing him ride the game See Double You to victory in a three-runner chase at Ayr in 2014 and enjoyed his celebration as he did his best impression of AP McCoy when winning the National in the last 100 yards.
For all his exuberance in the saddle it is probably fair to say McNally’s skills as a trainer are proving more obvious. The Jam Man has been his flag bearer for the last few seasons, steadily working his way up the handicap ranks to a hurdles rating in the 140s.
A 2 miles Class 3 flat handicap at York might not seem like the most obvious preparation for the Troytown Handicap Chase (Nov 8). He lined up off a mark of 129, far lower than his hurdles rating, his last chase run being a win in an eight-runner race around Cartmel in 2019, when eight pounds lower.
Well punted on the day, his price collapsed to 5/2 before the off. The Jam Man was given a perfect ride by Paul Townend as he made his challenge off the home turn, making rapid progress to the third last, he took the lead over the next. From there victory never looked in doubt, as it the words of commentator Jerry Hannon he “sluiced through the field” to win by 18 lengths.
A huge win for owner-trainer Ronan McNally, who suggested that he would be confident if The Jam Man made it to the third last. “He does all his best work in the home straight” he said, adding, “I wanted to save his mark for a big pot”. That pot, some 73,000 euros, he well and truly scooped here.
Triumph Hurdle clues
David Pipe unleashed his new French recruit, Adagio, to win at Warwick (Nov 6) on debut in a weak contest, but his runner had far more on his plate when tasked with backing up just eight days later.
His performance against Gordon Elliott’s Duffle Coat at Cheltenham (Nov 14) was a good one after only one start over hurdles. In a race run at a good tempo, Adagio was a bit keen in midfield through the early stages, while Duffle Coat was held up out the back. From the top of the hill Gordon Elliott’s runner was pushed along, seemingly outpaced, but came through to throw down a challenge to Adagio who had shot to the lead off the home turn. Stamina and experience won out up the hill, as Duffle Coat, was strongly driven out to hold onto a two-length advantage. If meeting again in the Triumph Hurdle, I would expect Adagio to get closer to Duffle Coat, but the later has a style of racing and staying ability that makes him highly attractive in a race that is usually run at a good gallop.
The Elliott yard have, as is often the case, an embarrassment of riches in the juvenile division. A Grade Three at Fairyhouse (Nov 29) saw the ex-Aga Kahn Zanahiyr ease clear from his rivals in the style of a top-quality prospect. That was a strongly run race too, remarkably some 10.20 seconds faster than the Grade One Royal Bond on the same card. A horse with a long and wonderfully fluid stride, Zanahiyr also looks a natural in the jumping department. Now at the top of the ante-post Triumph market, he looks set to take all the beating.
If there is any justice in the world it would only be right for Gary Moore to take this season’s Triumph Hurdle, after the heartbreak of Goshen last March. He may have a good chance with Nassalam, who skated in by no less than 59 lengths in a four-runner contest at Fontwell on his debut (Nov 15).
A gamble
A quiet Wednesday afternoon (Nov 18) at Hexham became a big story, as in the concluding handicap hurdle Phil Kirby’s Bushypark hacked up by 11 lengths to record a first success under rules.
Bushypark was the subject of a significant gamble that saw his price tumble from 16/1 to 7/4f in a matter of hours before the race. His improvement was difficult to spot, as he had shown next to nothing in four hurdles starts, including when beaten 21 lengths on handicap debut over course and distance in September.
The gamble was flagged up to the BHA by the Horseracing Bettors Forum and it produced quite a bit of criticism. However, it is not that uncommon. Horses that shorten up in the betting from the Phil Kirby yard tend to do well, so it was no surprise to see Bushypark win in the way that he did. I for one have nothing against small yards landing a punt.
Hail the headgear
Epatante was a seriously impressive winner of the Fighting Fifth at Newcastle in a race that fell apart due to Not So Sleepy’s antics at the first hurdle. She cemented her Champion Hurdle claims there but was overshadowed by the resurgence of Sandy Thomson’s Yorkhill in the Rehearsal Chase (Nov 28).
A horse that once held the unfabled position of being one of the most talented but difficult horses in training, Yorkhill had only won once in 15 starts for Willie Mullins since seemingly holding all before him when taking out the then JLT Novices’ Chase at the 2017 Festival.
A switch to Sandy Thomson’s Scottish Borders yard produced no immediate improvement as he toiled and pulled up in the Old Roan Chase at Aintree. However, things came good next time out as the veteran produced a stellar display from the front under Ryan Mania, outbattling the challenge of Whatmore close home to return victorious at 66/1.
He did that wearing a first-time tongue tie, a factor that should not be underestimated by punters. However, it would be wrong to suggest that this was not a superb training performance from Thompson who does so well with older horses from bigger yards.
After his success he added, “Harry The Viking (ex-Paul Nicholls, Borders National winner) was the model to go against to freshen these old horses up, you just fiddle away with them to get them right.”
If Yorkhill’s performance from the front was easy on the eye, Cloth Cap’s when winning the Ladbrokes Trophy was spectacular.
A horse that has been frustrating to follow, but one with latent talent was given a bold sight by Tom Scudamore in first-time cheek pieces and produced a faultless round of jumping.
Given his owner, a crack at the National in April might be on the cards and with the way he jumped around Newbury he looked like he should handle the Aintree fences. He is good ground dependent, but otherwise his trainer Jonjo O’Neill seemed somewhat bullish post-race, “If he gets his ground in the National, take the price now,” he said.
Ed Culham
Sign Up To Ed Culham Tips and get 30% discount on any subscription
You can get 30% discount, using the code – EDCULHAM30