Flying Childers Stakes Preview
Ed CulhamYou are here: Home /
Doncaster St Leger Meeting 11th – 14th September 2019
Friday 13th September
Wainwright’s Flying Childers Stakes (Group 2) (2 year old) 5 furlongs
Established in 1967, this race was originally named the Norfolk Stakes, but later became the Flying Childers in 1973. It drew its name from the famous 18th century Doncaster racehorse Flying Childers who went unbeaten in 6 career starts. He earned many admirers during his career, with many who saw him proclaiming him “the fastest horse ever to run at Newmarket” at the time. After racing Flying Childers also had a successful stud career, with many of his progeny good horses in their own right.
In recent years this contest has also founded the careers of a steady stream of sprint sires. Well known sire Zebedee won the race in 2010 and was followed in two subsequent years by Requinto and Sir Prancealot, both now established sires.
Frankie Dettori has won the Flying Childers more than any other jockey (5 times) and he could be set to add to his tally, having been booked to ride the favourite A’Ali who currently heads the market at 11/8. He certainly brings the best form into the race, with two Group 2 victories already to his name. He is followed in the market by Alligator Alley who won well in a Listed race last time out. This looks a weak renewal, with the 6 other runners needing to step up on what they have done already in order to get competitive. However, improvement is not ruled out from the likes of Golden Dragon and Seize The Time.
Trends
9/10 Winners had had 4 runs or more before lining up at Doncaster
8/10 Winners had run at Listed level or higher on their last outing
8/10 Had won at least a Listed race previously
6/10 Winners were dropping back to the minimum trip after running over 6 furlongs last time out
There have been 4 winning favourites in the last ten years, while there has only been 1 winner at odds of greater than 10/1 (Green Door 2013 – 18/1).
Runners
A’Ali – generally 11/8*
Standout performer in the race, has already won two contests at this level and chances are he will take some stopping. A worthy favourite.
Having run a respectable 5th in the Group 1 Prix Morny at Deauville last time, where he travelled like a good horse, he failed to show the late turn of foot that had won him his two Group 2s to date. That is however quite understandable considering the level of the opposition he faced in the Morny. Winner Earthlight is now unbeaten in all his 4 starts, so could be a bit special and between A’Ali and Earthlight were Royal Ascot Queen Mary winner Raffle Prize and Coventry winner Arizona.
There is clearly nothing of that level in this race, and A’Ali, with Dettori back aboard is the standout form pick. Perhaps though his Group 2 successes, in the Prix Robert Papin also at Deauville and the Norfolk Stakes at Ascot, weren’t of the highest level. A form line through a runner called Fan Club Rules makes for insightful reading. That horse was just over 3 lengths behind A’Ali when he won in Deauville and then was subsequently beaten a length by Alligator Alley in his next run at Goodwood. With Alligator Alley having experienced interference perhaps the margin could have been greater and there might not be too much between the two who head the market.
A further concern for A’Ali supporters is that the going at Doncaster looks set to be on the firm side for the week. Simon Crisford’s runner has never raced when soft hasn’t been in the going description.
While Prix Morny runners do have a good record when dropping down a level to race in this contest, there are several imponderables concerning A’Ali, making him one to take on.
Alligator Alley – 9/4
Steadily progressive over 5 furlongs, he gained his first win in patterned class at York last time out and looks one of the few who have potential to put it up to the favourite A’Ali.
His run at York deserves to be marked up, as he was impeded leaving the stalls, which left him at the tail of the field. Joseph O’Brien’s colt still had a lot of work to do going inside the last furlong and a half, but on entering the final furlong showed an impressive turn of foot which took him upsides and ultimately past the leaders.
Alligator Alley found similar trouble when running the time before at Goodwood where he finished 2nd behind Liberty Beach (back in 5th was Wheels On Fire). He was hampered when switching track position at a crucial stage just 1 furlong out and had that not happened the gap between 1st and 2nd would surely have been closer than a length. Liberty Beach has since gone on to confirm the form with a strong 2nd place finish in the Group 2 Gimcrack Stakes.
This colt looks the type who should appreciate a rapidly run 5 furlongs on fast ground, as he certainly has the potential and ability to stay further than this. Although a strong pace is not certain, with no compulsive front runners in the field, horses like Wheels On Fire are likely to be up there near the lead. A’Ali may also appreciate a strong gallop and like to move through the field from the tail, so track position and timing may be crucial. At the prices Alligator Alley looks more appealing.
Wheels On Fire – 7/1
Ex French trained, having his first start for Aidan F Fogarty after finishing behind Alligator Alley at Goodwood last time. Needs to find improvement.
Ran a decent race at Goodwood, showed bright early speed and moved well when hitting the front going inside the final furlong. However, his effort when getting to the lead left much to be desired as he tied up badly and faded in the last 100 yards. One of those that passed him late on was Alligator Alley, who finished to good effect.
In 6 runs so far he has recorded 1 victory, but most revealing is perhaps that in 4 of those 6 starts he has been run down in the last 100 yards or so of his races, a fact that would suggest he is not an especially strong stayer. A change of yard may yet get more out of Wheels On Fire, but I would be inclined to take him on until we see a better performance.
Want FREE Horse Racing tips every day from our team of Professional Tipsters?
Flaming Princess – 11/1
A Listed winner, who has been campaigned at a high level and largely not disgraced in Group 2 and 3 company. Not so far off the standard required.
Finished 3rd in the Prix d’Arenburg at Chantilly latest when running out of room after tracking the leaders, with Christophe Soumillon having to switch late on. That then wasn’t a bad performance. Before she had readily won a 6 runner Deauville Listed race, beating fellow English raider Kemble into 2nd. That horse hasn’t done much to advertise the form since and I have the suspicion it was a weak contest.
She is also untested on quick ground. I don’t get the feeling she is improving and she would need to to take a hand in this contest.
Golden Dragon – 12/1
Only had three races so far, with the most recent two both being victories. Has a lot to find but could be the runner open to most improvement tackling a higher grade for the first time.
His Windsor win came only three weeks ago, where he travelled well into the contest and looked to have the race in safe keeping from the furlong pole. Under pressure he veered away from the whip, running into the open centre of the track which allowed King’s Lynn to close late, with Golden Dragon just winning the decision by a short head. The time before he had also won at Windsor, when then he showed a likeable turn of foot to kick away from the field. Again, he looked inexperienced under the whip, something that may count against him as he takes on a better class of horse.
Firm ground should suit, as might the drop back to 5 furlongs. If Oisin Murphy can get him to settle and keep him straight at the finish he could run into a place.
Dream Shot – 16/1
2 wins from 6 runs, but those have come at some way below this level (class 4). Would be a surprise winner.
Last run came at York, where he didn’t get much luck in running when bumped and hampered coming inside the last furlong. He didn’t look the easiest ride then though, as he seemed to want to lug right handed. At the finish he was some 4 ½ lengths behind Alligator Alley. Perhaps his best performance came at Sandown, when only beaten ½ length by Liberty Beach.
Hasn’t really run up to that level in 3 subsequent starts and again looked a difficult ride in the Richmond Stakes at Goodwood. Passed over.
Seize The Time – 22/1
Won a Beverley novice event before failing to step up in Listed class on her second start.
There have been one or two winners to come out of the July novice race that Seize The Time won. That said the Newbury Listed race she contested was a weak affair and she didn’t look like she was able to go the pace in that encounter.
May appreciate the return to a sounder surface. Ryan Moore catches the eye as a booking, but she has it all to do.
Emtem – 33/1
Ran a huge race when 5th at 80/1 behind A’Ali in the Norfolk Stakes at the Royal meeting. Has subsequently failed to prove that that was not a fluke in two starts since. Still has time on her side, but she doesn’t look poised to strike here.
*Prices correct at time of writing.
Verdict
There seems a sizable difference between the top two in the market and the rest, and while there are several unexposed contenders who could improve, they are graduating from such a low level it’s difficult to see them troubling the principals. A’Ali brings the best form to the table, but I suspect he might still be slightly overrated after his two Group 2 triumphs in what weren’t the greatest of races. A horse who appears to be developing and showing maturity in his races is ALLIGATOR ALLEY, whose latest performance at York, when he had a lot of trouble to overcome in running, proved just that. A strongly run contest would suit him and he is proven on quick ground, something that can’t be said for A’Ali. He then shades the vote. Golden Dragon is taken to improve radically from his Windsor runs and may pip Flaming Princess to complete the frame.
1 – ALLIGATOR ALLEY
2 – A’ALI
3 – GOLDEN DRAGON
Ed Culham
28 day trials are still available
We still have places left for our £2.99 trials with our Tipsters. That’s just over £0.10 per day with some incredible returns being made recently.