Ebor Heritage Handicap Preview
Ed CulhamYou are here: Home /
Day 4 – Saturday 24th August
Ebor Heritage Handicap (Class 2) (4 year old+) 1 mile 6 furlongs
The highlight of the last day of the festival and a real spectacle with 22 runners set to fan out across the Knavesmire. This historic handicap has been run since 1843, when a horse called Pagan wrote his name into the history books as the first winner. Now the most valuable handicap in Europe, with this year marking the first £1 million running. With such riches on offer it’s no surprise that the Ebor in recent years has attracted some high quality horses, runners like last year’s winner Muntahaa who was already a Group race performer. Muntahaa won off a mark of 109, the highest in the last 10 years. However, since 2009 there have only been four winners off marks below 100, with the lowest rated of those being Willie Mullins’ Sesenta who triumphed off 94.
In the past several winners of this contest have gone on to have a stab at the richest handicap of them all, the Melbourne Cup. Muntahaa could only manage 9th Down Under, 2017 winner Nakeeta finished a strong 5th while Heartbreak City, successful in 2016, was agonisingly denied by a head on the Flemington line.
This year again there are several heavyweight Group race performers near the top of the ante-post market, with Salouen, Red Verdon and Raheen House all accustomed to running at a higher level. Indeed, of the ten runners at the head of the market only three have never run in Group company, those being Outbox, Royal Line and current 6/1 favourite King’s Advice, who has been a revelation this season. Mark Johnston’s runner has won 8/9 races since early March 2019, a sequence which has seen his mark astronomically from 71 to his Ebor rating of 112.
There are still 56 entries left in the race at the time of writing, but with a maximum of 22 able to compete, shake ups in the market are a given between now and Saturday. With that in mind it’s not necessary to look into each runner in depth, I will instead endeavour to comment on the chances of the more likely protagonists. But first here are some all-important trends to think about.
Trends – Last 10 Years
9/10 Winners were aged 5 years or older (Tiger Cliff (2013) was the only 4 year old winner in recent years)
7/10 Winners had previously won at least a Class 2 handicap
7/10 Winners had placed on their last run
7/10 Winners carried between 9-00 and 9-04
6/10 Winners have had a rating of 100 or higher
6/10 Winners had had 3 runs or more before lining up in the Ebor
5/10 Winners had raced between 6 and 16 times previously
4/10 Winners had run at York at least once in their career previously, with only Heartbreak City (2016) having triumphed on the Knavesmire before
4/10 Winners have returned at odds of 20/1 or more
4/10 Winners were stepping up in trip from their previous run
1/10 Had previously won a Group race (Muntahaa – 2018)
0/10 Winners have returned as the SP favourite
Runners
King’s Advice – Generally 6/1*
Been a revelation this season, winning 8 of 9 starts, including big races at the Newmarket July Meeting and Glorious Goodwood. Clearly hugely progressive but will need to come on again to claim this prize.
Last time out at Goodwood over the Ebor trip of 1 mile 6 furlongs he travelled supremely well behind the leaders, but when wound up in the straight he looked at one point to be in trouble when rival Outbox passing him. King’s Advice battled back tenaciously under a cool Joe Fanning, who never looked as though he was going for everything (though that is Fanning’s style) aboard the 7/2 favourite. That suggests he may have still more to offer, and while he now concedes a 2lb swing to Outbox who re-opposes that might not be enough to reverse placings.
This is a horse I like and who you can count on to produce his best. His run style, with low head carriage is often typical of a horse that gives their all. His only below par run this season has been in the Northumberland Plate, when he had excuses as he had to come wide into the straight, from the rear of the field and while staying on well at the finish couldn’t reach the leaders, finishing 5th. That was his first try over 2 miles, and perhaps for now this trip, over which his record stands at 4/4 is more suitable. Word has it after the Ebor he will step up to patterned class, and he shouldn’t be far off that level.
Not opposed lightly but taking on horses with Group race experience might find him out this time and there isn’t much juice in his price of 6/1. Percentage call to take him on.
Withhold – 8/1
Lightly raced, ex Northumberland Plate winner who returned after a long absence to win the Marsh Cup at Newbury last month.
A horse that likes to front run, Withhold wasn’t pestered for the lead at Newbury on his return with Jason Watson able to set his own fractions out front. That allowed his rider to steadily wind things up, meaning nothing could get to his quarters as he stayed on dourly from 3 furlongs out. Joint favourite that day was Proschema, who Withhold comfortably disposed of by about 7 lengths, but that same rival was almost double that distance behind King’s Advice next time out at Goodwood. Still, he also beat a very reliable yardstick in Who Dares Wins, a horse who had previously won the Northumberland Plate at Newcastle and in doing so finished in front of King’s Advice.
It is unlikely that Rodger Charlton’s horse will be allowed as easy a lead as at Newbury, which may not be to his liking. The trip also has to be a slight question mark, as his record at trips 2 miles or longer stands at 4/5 while at anything less than 2 miles it is a far from impressive 1/8.
Has to be resected given connections, who are likely to have laid him out for a go at the £600,000 first prize, but he may need more of a stamina test and so is passed over.
Raheen House – 8/1
Seasoned Group race performer who is making a belated handicap debut. Certainly one of the class horses in the race, but whether he stays well enough for a contest like this remains to be seen.
Just went down by a neck to Red Verdon when last seen over course and distance with both running off level weights. He now gets a 3lb swing with that rival and looks capable of reversing the form. Both runs this season have been at York, with William Haggas possibly campaigning him with this race in mind.
Handicap debut off 109, but capable of going very well, although poor win rate (3 from 17) and the fact other runners may be stronger stayers make him avoidable for win purposes.
Ben Vrackie – 10/1
Lightly raced 4 year old for John Gosden who was a disappointing favourite last time in the Bet365 Trophy Handicap at Newmarket, but had run well before that.
His run at Newmarket, when he was well behind both King’s Advice and Outbox, left a lot to be desired as he faded tamely when asked to close, and was ultimately beaten 14 lengths. Before that at Ascot, over a trip of a mile and a half, he had just failed to run down Baghdad.
Whether he stays 1 mile 6 furlongs effectively enough is still open to question, and he has been raised 4lbs from his Newmarket run. Not particularly encouraging.
Royal Line – 10/1
Another with low mileage for John Gosden. Made a mockery of his mark in the November Handicap last season. Has questions to answer but may well be up to the task.
Was second top weight with a mark of 105, but turned a competitive race into a procession when winning on soft ground at Doncaster. Couldn’t continue his winning ways in one start this season though, when 4th in a Listed race won by Elarqam. He led from the front then but couldn’t maintain that position over an inadequate 1 mile 2 furlongs. Now running off 111, he steps up to 1 mile 6 furlongs for the first time.
From the way he sprinted clear between the last two furlongs at Doncaster on testing ground he shouldn’t have an issue with an extra 2 furlongs at York. There are questions about his ability to handle firm ground however, having never won on anything firmer than good. John Gosden seemed to keep him to easier going last season and he may need some juice in the ground to be seen to full effect. Potential ground issues temper enthusiasm somewhat, but this mark should be within range and a likely player.
Want FREE Horse Racing tips every day from our team of Professional Tipsters?
Baghdad – 12/1
Hugely likeable performer who rarely runs a bad race. Now steps up in trip in an attempt to find a bit more improvement.
Another son of Frankel in this race who seems to relish a test of stamina. He has contested Group races the last twice and was far from disgraced in the Group 3 Glorious Stakes at Goodwood last time. He led the field but couldn’t quite last home when passed in the final furlong. He still easily defeated Prince Of Arran, a rival that may line up in the Ebor also. That was a run that gives reason for hope now that he steps up to 1 mile 6 furlongs for the first time, as he didn’t stop in his run to the line for all Frankie Dettori’s letting him coast home when he was passed.
Now 5lbs higher than when winning the Duke Of Edinburgh Handicap at the Royal meeting, but with experience in Group race company, and if improving for the step up in trip he could be a factor.
Outbox – 14/1
3 from 3 as a 2 year old but has found things tougher this season. Looks a nice prospect but needs to find more to be beating old rival King’s Advice.
Has twice been beaten by Mark Johnston’s horse and at Goodwood looked to have few excuses. In fact, he could even be accused of throwing the race away that time as he clearly hit the front in the last furlong but did little once there and was passed by a more willing rival. He looks a more impressive horse than King’s Advice, but perhaps one with less substance. What is alarming for his backers is that he displayed the same tendency earlier in the season when running in a Chantilly Listed race. As at Goodwood he travelled up well on the outside of runners, before hitting the front, but was run down by a fast finishing rival and beaten a head on the line.
He has now been beaten twice this season by close margins. With a 2lbs swing for his 2nd behind King’s Advice you have to think he has a sound chance of getting the better of that rival, which would put him in the firmly in contention for this race. However, having seen potential issues with his attitude I know who I would rather side with at York.
Mustajeer – 16/1
Irish raider who ran well in this contest last year when finishing 4th off the same mark of 108.
This season he has been campaigned more aggressively by Ger Lyons, with 4 runs in Group company. At Navan in the Group 3 Vintage Crop Stakes he put in a fine performance when staying on well, only to be outbattled by Master Of Reality, finishing 2nd in front of A P O’Brien’s Southern France. Master Of Reality has since gone on to prove his class when finishing 3rd in the Ascot Gold Cup, while Southern France got back to winning ways in the recent Irish St Ledger Trial. Mustajeer was again closely matched with that rival in his last outing, a Group 2 at the Curragh, when finishing a head behind that runner in 5th. Those runs over the Ebor trip show he should be competitive on the same mark as last year (108) and if the ground is on the quick side, he could be a serious threat.
Endured a tough run in the Ebor last year, when coming right from the back of the field and finishing quickly for 4th. Off the same mark, he looks a strong each way play.
Salouen – 16/1
Similar profile to Red Verdon, except that this will be his handicap debut. Has struggled in some top class contests of late, including the Ascot King George and Coronation Cup at Epsom. Should appreciate this drop in class but has to shoulder top weight and 9-10 is a lot to lump in a race like this. Also needs to show a liking for this new trip of 1 mile 6 furlongs as well as his current well being. Too many questions to answer.
Kelly’s Dino – 20/1
Contested the Group 3 John Smith’s Silver Cup over course and distance in July, finishing 5th behind Red Verdon and Raheen House. Gets 3 and 2 pounds from those rivals respectively so could close the gap, but the trip looks an issue.
After his Silver Cup run, he won narrowly over a trip of 1 mile 4 furlongs, when just holding on from rival Corelli at the finish. Now shoulders a 4lbs penalty and has never looked like he would benefit from this step up in trip. His record at trips over 1 mile 4 stands at 0 from 4 runs and I think that looks set to continue here.
Red Verdon – 20/1
Hugely experienced, globe trotting runner whose last run in a handicap came in May 2016 when with a rating of 88.
Triumphed in the John Smith’s Silver Cup latest, when seeing off rivals Kelly’s Dino, Weekender and Raheen House. He potentially meets those rivals again giving at most 3lbs away to Kelly’s Dino. With the exception of perhaps Raheen House, that doesn’t look to be enough for those horses to overturn the deficit from last time. That win came over course and distance and he looks to be a strong contender.
Mekong – 20/1
Standout runs behind Dee Ex Bee in a Group 3 earlier in the season when beaten just over a length and then again at Sandown when pipped by Dermot Weld’s promising Falcon Eight. His mark took a battering last season, after a 7 length demolition job in a handicap on heavy ground at Haydock, when running off 94. Now rated 110, but his performances this season have caught the eye and he still looks mildly progressive. Place chance.
Others
Too many to mention.
Last year’s 2nd Weekender is now 1lb lower and capable of another big run, but he hasn’t been in the same form as when lining up in this race last year.
Tim Easterby’s Wells Farhh Go makes his handicap debut, but a mark of 112 looks plenty high enough given what he has achieved this season.
Willie Mullins has another strong group of runners, including last year’s favourite Stratum who runs off the same mark as last year (102). He was disappointing when favourite for the Northumberland Plate this season. Last time out in the Galway Hurdle marked mild improvement, but he can only be watched on what he has achieved since his last run at York.
Buildmeupbuttercup won a maiden on the flat at Galway in good style and has only been raise 4lbs for that. Stepping up in trip she could be one further down the weights to keep an eye on.
Elsewhere for Mullins, a handicap mark of 110 looks a little harsh on what True Self has achieved thus far.
Lastly, Cleonte of Andrew Balding’s, who ran a stormer in last year’s Cesarewitch when 3rd off 95 is now 10lbs higher and could probably use more of a test of stamina.
Verdict
A hugely difficult race to call, with proven Group horses like Raheen House, Red Verdon and Salouen taking on up and coming types such as Royal Line, Outbox and King’s Advice. The last mentioned should run a huge race and I don’t think the handicapper has necessarily caught up with him yet, but he may find one or two in here on better marks. MUSTAJEER ran well in this last year, when held up and not experiencing much luck in running. He races off the same mark on Saturday and with connections sure he now stays the trip he may be more prominently positioned. Good ground or quicker should suit and I expect him to be challenging at the finish. A whole array of possible dangers lurk in wait, with Royal Line definitely figuring highly. At Doncaster last November he looked to have a real engine and while higher in the weights now this lightly raced son of Dubawi could find improvement. Others who warrant serious consideration are Raheen House, the hugely consistent Baghdad, Mekong and Withhold.
1 – MUSTAJEER
2 – ROYAL LINE
3 – BAGHDAD
4 – MEKONG
5 – RAHEEN HOUSE
Ed Culham
28 day trials are still available
We still have places left for our £2.99 trials with our Tipsters.
At the time of writing, our best performing Tipster was CD Racing. Over the past 28 days you would’ve made £303.50 profit to £10 stakes. Incredible results!