Supreme Novices Hurdle Preview
With Ed CulhamYou are here: Home /
2020 Cheltenham Festival – Supreme Novices’ Hurdle Preview
With little over two weeks until the ‘Cheltenham roar’ sounds, it’s time to look in depth at some of the major contests and see how they might play out on the day. What better place to start than in the Festival curtain raiser, the Sky Bet Supreme Novices’ Hurdle.
Race History
Known as the Gloucestershire Hurdle from its inauguration in 1946, in those early years the race was often split into two or more divisions. Legendary trainer Vincent O’Brien achieved an unprecedented ten wins in the race between 1952 and 1959, and where it not for Tokora’s victory in division one of 1957, O’Brien would have achieved a clean sweep in the race from 1956-58.
From 1972 onwards the race has been run in its current guise, becoming known as the Supreme Novices’ when Waterford Crystal began sponsorship of the race in 1978.
In more recent years a new Irish supremo has made the contest his own. It’s often forgotten, given his more recent domination, that Willie Mullins won his first Supreme back in 1995 with Tourist Attraction. He then had to wait another 12 years until tasting victory again with Ebaziyan, before then recording a hattrick of successes in 2013, 2014 and 2015, with Champagne Fever and the superstar duo of Vautour and Douvan. The 2016 contest would also have gone the way of Mullins, where it not for the irrepressible force that was and is Altior. Both of the following years the prize went elsewhere, before Klassical Dream made it a sixth win in the race for the Wizard of Closutton in 2019.
Past winners
2019 – KLASSICAL DREAM (age 5), 2 runs prior to Supreme (38 days between runs then 37 until Supreme)
Form (in same season up until Supreme): 11
RPRs: 129—145—(160 Supreme)
2018 – SUMMERVILLE BOY (6), 4 runs, (28d—25d—21d—37d S)
Form: 2231
RPRs: 120—137—130—150—156(S)
2017 – LABAIK (6), 5 starts, 3 runs (2 refused to race), (30d—105d—15d S),
Form: 11RR6
RPRs: 126—143—46—157(S)
2016 – ALTIOR (6), 4 runs, (20d—14d—40d—80d S),
Form: 1111
RPRs: 136—148—146—157—166(S)
2015 – DOUVAN (5), 2 runs, (46d—59d S),
Form: 11
RPRs: 143—149—160(S)
2014 – VAUTOUR (5), 3 runs, (34d—28d—29d S),
Form: 111
RPRs: 140—145—150—158(S)
2013 – CHAMPAGNE FEVER (6), 4 runs, (13d—34d—33d—30d S),
Form: 1231
RPRs: 130—150—112—150—162(S)
2012 – CINDERS AND ASHES (5), 4 runs, (14d—26d—21d—51d S),
Form: 2111
RPRs: 129—145—128—144—151(S)
2011 – AL FEROF (6), 4 runs, (18d—21d—22d—30d S),
Form: F311
RPRs: 123—138—121—142—155(S)
2010 – MENORAH (5), 4 runs (29d—14d—54d—23d S),
Form: 1212
RPRs: 124—137—151—141—150(S)
Trends
9/10 Had run in a Graded race in the lead up to the Supreme
8/10 Had won on their last start
8/10 Had won a Graded contest, of those eight 5 had won a Grade One, 2 a Grade Two and 1 a Grade 3 (2010 – Menorah and 2011 – Al Ferof had not won a Graded race)
7/10 Recorded their best RPR in their run before lining up in the Supreme
6/10 Had 4 runs before Cheltenham
5/10 Had recorded an RPR of 150 or over previously
5/10 Ran within a month of their last start, 2 at 30-40 days and 3 at 50 days plus
3/10 Had run previously at Cheltenham
Runners
Shishkin – currently 5/2
3 runs, (27d—21d—32d until Supreme)
Form: F11
RPRs: NA—140—154
Big horse, who will make a chaser in time. Looks to have no shortage of speed, but also the ability to stay further than a bare 2 miles, which is always an advantage in the Supreme.
Fell on hurdles debut but visually extremely impressive in two completed runs since, winning by over 10 lengths on each occasion. At Newbury (15th Jan), he travelled well and was accurate at his hurdles. He then displayed an impressive turn of foot on heavy ground to stretch away, easily pulling clear at the finish. Shishkin then followed up at Huntingdon over 2 miles 3 furlongs.
Shishkin’s nearest rival at Newbury had previously run to a mark of 123, when beaten by another Henderson runner. Both times that horse had failed to live with the pace of the Henderson runners, and certainly on pedigree he looks more a staying type. Shishkin should have been far too quick for him. Otherwise, the form of that maiden looks weak, with eight horses having failed to place on their next run. At Huntington, he beat Shan Blue (139 rated), a horse that hasn’t really gone on after a promising start to his career over hurdles.
Shishkin does have a wonderful fluid way of travelling and may well be suited by a race run a true gallop, but he faces plenty of new tests in the Supreme. He will have to be slicker at his hurdles now facing several rivals with more experience and higher levels of form – his three closest rivals in the betting have all won Grade One races. Shishkin has had an unusual preparation for a Supreme bid, beginning reasonably late (18th Dec.) and considering he fell on debut, he only had his first full run over hurdles as recently as mid-January. Nicky Henderson has got one more run into him, but he remains very inexperienced with just four runs under rules. His current rating (154) would already have been good enough to win more than one Supreme in the last ten years, but I do feel that this horse has been over hyped. He lacks experience and standout form, so 5/2 has to be a price factoring in a lot of potential, and for me too much.
Asterion Forlonge – 4/1
3 runs (1 NHF), (44d—27d—36d S)
Form: 111
RPRs: 117—141—156
Strong grey gelding, who likes to lead. Has shown a tendency to jump right-handed at his hurdles. Stays strongly, but whether he has the pace for the Supreme remains to be seen.
Willie Mullins has taken the same route to the Supreme Novices’ with this horse as with many of his past winners, (also won Leopardstown G1 registered as the ‘Brave Inca’). He disputed the lead in that race for much of the way with a horse who looks bound to contest a race over a longer trip at the Festival. That rival out jumped Asterion Forlonge at almost all the hurdles down the back straight, with the Mullins horse high through the air at times and always having to be corrected after jumping right handed. It’s testament to his ability that he was able to overcome those difficulties. He powered clear after the turn in, but in doing so appeared to hang to his left (towards rail) and seemed unbalanced.
That Paul Townend had chosen to ride Mt Leinster (beaten 13 ½ lengths) that day at Leopardtown, suggests that this performance wasn’t necessarily expected and Willie Mullins has pointed out that this was a horse they considered to be more of a 3 miler, but one who has surprised them with his speed on the racecourse.
The current crop of novice hurdlers in the Mullins’ camp don’t look up to the standard of past seasons, especially when you consider that Asterion Forlonge’s win at Leopardstown was remarkably Mullins’ first major novice hurdle win of the season.
For me there are several major doubts about this horse. Most notably his jumping, which currently isn’t fluent or straight enough to win a Supreme. If making the same errors as at Leopardstown he won’t have the time to account for them. Another potential warning sign was his tendency to hang when hitting the front last time. Cheltenham with its undulations requires a finely balanced horse and he can’t afford to be hanging when racing up the hill after the last. As a runner that likes to lead, he may struggle to dictate in the Supreme, and if throwing in jumping errors could find things happening all too quickly for him.
Abacadabras – 5/1
4 runs, (36d—20d—25d—73d S)
Form: 1121
RRPs: 137—149—151—146
Rangy type, with a low cutting racing action. Has gained good experience in four runs over hurdles this season and has only found stablemate Envoi Allen (current short priced favourite for the Ballymore) too good.
That form from the Fairyhouse Royal Bond (1st Dec.) is the best on offer, with both Envoi Allen and Abacadabras going on to win Grade Ones since. The third placed runner also advertised the form, with a close second in the Irish Champion Hurdle at Leopardstown, while Soviet Pimpernel, some 20 lengths back in 6th followed up comfortably in Grade Three company next time. Gordon Elliott’s runner will have learnt a lot from what was a rough race, as he had to work his own opening to get out from centre field, before travelling well on the outside of runners to press Envoi Allen over the last. That move was an energy sapping one and had he been closer to Envoi Allen before the last he might have been able to use his pace to better effect.
Abacadabras can appear scratchy at his hurdles, when sometimes getting in too close, but he does tend to make a true hurdling shape over his obstacles and is quick through the air. He appears to benefit from being held up, using his pace to come through and strike near the finish in his races. Whether he stays as strongly as some of his rivals is open to doubt, but he has hit the line well in his races to date, which suggests that unless the going was testing, he should have no difficulties. Gordon Elliott believes good ground and a strong pace could bring about more improvement from this runner. Despite being around 5/1 in the market, he looks reasonably forgotten given the hype around Shishkin and on form makes plenty of appeal.
Fiddlerontheroof – 6/1
4 runs, (28d—27d—27d—65d S)
Form: 2211
RPRs: 137—131—146—152
A straightforward type who can race prominently but doesn’t have to. Is another who has acquired plenty of experience, in four hurdles starts this season, including an impressive Grade One win at Sandown (Tolworth Hurdle. 4th Jan.) last time.
Made debut over 2m 3f at Chepstow (11th Oct.), when headed late on by stronger stayer. Reverted to 2 miles next time at Wincanton and looked slightly outpaced on what was better ground (Good/Good-Soft) when the race quickened and couldn’t recover after being headed. In next two starts at Sandown (2 miles, both on heavy ground), he travelled well and was well on top at the line after quickening and staying best in the testing conditions.
Formwise, there is a suspicion he hasn’t had to beat all that much in his last two contests. Second placed Jeremys Flame had been beaten in two Mares contests before the Tolworth. More concerning was the fact he was outpaced by Edwardstone at Wincanton, when encountering better going. While this horse makes a good shape over his hurdles and is consistent, I can see him being outpaced at Cheltenham. Were the ground to ride testing on the opening day however, he might come into the equation.
Envoi Allen – 2/1 to 8/1
3 runs, (28d—34d—64d S)
Form: 111
RPRs: 149—153—153
In all likelihood he will run in the Ballymore Novices’ Hurdle on day two. Gordon Elliott has left him in the Supreme in the event of the ground being testing on the first day but has said he would only run in the race if ‘Heavy’ was in the going description. Were he to run however, he would be favourite and hard to beat.
Chantry House – 8/1
2 runs, (57d—30d S)
Form: 11
RPRs: 139—140
Unbeaten since joining Nicky Henderson. Comfortably beat Edwardstone by over 3 lengths in a bumper last season and now two from two over hurdles this term.
His first start over timber came at Cheltenham (13th Dec.). They went a very sedate pace early on, with Chantry House keen, but gradually quickened going down the back straight. His jumping seemed to improve as the pace lifted and looked efficient. After a slight error at the second last, he momentarily looked outpaced, but I liked the way he snapped back on the bridle challenging on the way to the last. In a contest that turned into a sprint from the home turn, Chantry House showed good speed to master his challengers after jumping the last (ran the last two furlongs in 28.9 seconds). That same ability to quicken was in evidence next time at Newbury, when he ranged alongside the long-time leader, before quickly putting the race to bed when shaken up.
The idea that this horse doesn’t have the speed for the Supreme looks unfounded and he could well prove the type who does better in races run at a stronger gallop. The Cheltenham race that he ran in looks a strong contest, with the second since winning Haydock’s Supreme Trial (Stolen Silver). Of the runners behind the front two, six next time out runs resulted in 2 wins, 3 places with only one runner failing to place. It was pleasing to see this horse really have to race on just his first start and I think in raw form terms he has achieved more than stablemate Shishkin. Has form on good and soft ground and if lining up (entered in the Ballymore) looks a real contender.
Captain Guinness – 12/1
2 runs (1 NHF), (27d—47d S)
Form: 12
RPRs: 137—147
Ran a huge race on hurdles debut in the Moscow Flyer at Punchestown, when just edged out by Gordon Elliott’s bright prospect Andy Dufresne on the run to the line. The pair were well clear of the third and with improvement to come he could still be anything.
His inexperience probably told at Punchestown, as he appeared hard to settle and his rider had little option but to let him tug his way to the front from halfway. That left him with little to repel the challenge of his rival in the closing stages.
Coming into the Supreme on the back of just one run is no mean feat and it would take a mighty performance from this horse to win. He would need to settle far better than at Punchestown and learn to race so as not to expend energy before the finish. From his high knee action, he may be a horse suited to a softer surface. Were he to line up and the going to suit, I would still find it hard to be confident of his chances after only one hurdle run.
Sporting John – 8/1 to 16/1
3 runs, (30d—70d—23d S)
Form: 111
RPRs: 131—135—152
Tall, strong son of Getaway who has done very little wrong in three hurdles starts this season.
Began at Exeter (5th Nov.), where he looked novicey at times. In the home straight he took a while to get to the leaders but displayed a smart turn of foot after the last to win with plenty in hand. Back at Exeter next time, he cruised home in a weak race, when showing improvement in the jumps department. Stepped up to 2 miles 3 furlongs most recently, when running out a 6 ½ length winner from two good rivals on soft-heavy ground.
Has a high knee action and I would be a bit concerned about this horse at a trip of 2 miles on better ground. It’s important to travel well in the Supreme and this horse does seem to hit a small flat spot in his races before coming back to life. Clearly made for fences in time, he also tends to throw in a few big leaps at his hurdles. Having tried him over an extended trip last time, I’d be surprised if he lined up in the Supreme, with the Ballymore much more likely to be his race.
Allart – 20/1
3 runs, (74d—33d—19d S)
Form: F11
RPRS: NA—134—144
Beaten by Edwardstone on sole bumper start last season.
Fell at the first on hurdles debut and off over two months after that. Returned with easy win at Ludlow (16th Jan.), when jumping well and coming through stylishly to lead after the second last. Followed up in what looked a poor novice event at Doncaster. Clearly has potential, but he will face a whole new test against Graded level horses. His last run only leaves 19 days until Cheltenham, and he will probably be found wanting if taking his chance.
Elixir D’Anay – 20/1
3 runs, (56d—26d—37d S)
Form: 125
RPRs: 144—149—143
Won well on first hurdle start (2m 3f Soft-Heavy) from a smart rival. Since then has been steadily stepped up in trip and was quickly mastered by Envoi Allen at Naas next time out. That was still a fine effort, with the same rival he had beaten on hurdles debut back in third. The decision to go up a further 2 furlongs in trip next time out seemed a strange one and he was beaten before the last there. His form with Envoi Allen would clearly bring him into the picture for the Supreme, but I wonder whether he would have the pace for 2 miles around the Old Course. Soft ground gives him more of a chance, but I have doubts about his attitude when challenged and after a poor run last time, am happy to leave him alone.
Edwardstone – 20/1
3 runs, (27d—41d—51d S)
Form: 112
RPRs: 131—142—142
Strong, thickset gelding who looks to have had a nice preparation for this race.
Ran a fine race on hurdles debut at Wincanton, where he was keen early on, but travelled well into contention before having a good scrap with Fiddlerontheroof up the run in. That rival had the benefit of a run, but Edwardstone outsprinted his rival on the run to the last and also showed good battling qualities to hold on at the line. Next time out at Aintree, he was held up at the tail of the field, but even when running beyond halfway showed signs of being keen. He travelled well into contention, before gritting it out in a tight finish after the last. Sported a hood next time in the Haydock Supreme Trial, where again he travelled well from the back of the field, but the heavy going looked to blunt his speed. Looked like winning, only to be caught on the line by Stolen Silver who came home with a wet sail.
I would be inclined to forgive him his Haydock run, in what was a tactical affair. He will need to switch off at the back in the Supreme, but a strong pace should allow him to do so. Heavy ground didn’t look to suit, and a sounder surface would enhance his chances. Experience in close finishes should have hardened this horse and will stand him in good stead. While I’m not sure he has the quality to win a Supreme he will surely be finishing to good effect and looks a nice each way play.
Master Debonair – 25/1
4 runs, (27d—27d—56d—23d S)
Form: 2113
RRPs: 127—137—145—140
Form this season leaves him with work to do.
I think we learnt a lot about this horse on hurdles debut at Cheltenham, where he looked to be coming through to win the race rounding the home turn, only to be outbattled. Heaven Help Us who triumphed that day was beaten 8 lengths by Abacadabras at Leopardstown in December. Master Debonair likes to dictate in his races and subsequently won two small field events at Ascot, including the Ascot Supreme Trial. He was impressive there on heavy ground when quickening from the front, but again had his limitations exposed when challenged more recently over 2m 3f. Won’t be able to dictate in the Supreme and he is likely to struggle to get involved in the finish.
Thebannerkingrebel – 20/1 to 66/1
6 runs, (24d—150d—20d—56d—20d—30d S)
Form: 11F13(17)
RPRs: 117—139—147—142—148—131
Began the season early with two hurdle runs in the summer months. Fell on return after a break when looking like he would have won at Wetherby. Made amends in Listed company at Haydock and then slightly unlucky when squeezed out on the run behind Stolen Silver and Edwardstone. Showed nothing of that form most recently, tailed off in the Betfair Hurdle on handicap debut. Looks a speedy type who is probably better on good ground. On figures has quite a bit to find though, especially after a poor run last time.
Stolen Silver – 20/1 to 50/1
5 runs, (27d—20d—35d—20d—30d S)
Form: UR1218
RPRs: 119—127—140—143—143
Looks a very strong stayer at this trip, having got up in the dying strides to deny Edwardstone in the Haydock Supreme Trial. Before that he also exhibited potential when staying on to finish just over a length behind Chantry House at Cheltenham (13th Dec.). His latest run in the Betfair Hurdle wasn’t a bad one, when outpaced but coming home with a late rattle to finish 6th. That came on good ground, so it’s likely that at this trip he would need plenty of rain. He is entered in four races at the Festival and is probably more likely to step up in trip rather than run here.
Beacon Edge – 33/1
2 runs, (130d—15d S)
Form: 12
RPRs: 132—147
Closely matched with Envoi Allen and Abacadabras in bumpers last season, when seen finishing late and beaten by only 3 ¼ lengths and ¾ of a length by those rivals respectively. Wasn’t fluent on hurdles debut at Punchestown but quickened well after jumping the third last and was left clear after rival fell at the last. Given a lengthy break, he reappeared recently when just losing out in a tight finish in Grade Two company. In a race that turned into a sprint, it was a novicey jumping error at the last flight that probably cost Beacon Edge the race. Andy Dufresne was back in 3rd that day, which points to an impressive performance from this horse on only his second hurdles start.
As a horse that looks a strong stayer, he may well be stepped up in trip (Ballymore and Albert Bartlett entires). Inexperience may well hinder Beacon Edge’s chances, but he clearly has no shortage of ability and if the ground were soft, he would rate a live outsider in the Supreme.
Conclusions
It’s too early to say, but after the recent wet weather which looks set to continue into next week the going could easily be soft or worse on the opening day of the festival.
In an aim to cover all bases, I’m going to select four horses, two that I would fancy if the ground is good-soft or better and two if the going is testing.
In the event that the rain continues to fall (looking likely at the moment) my suggestion would be CHANTRY HOUSE who may have only had two hurdles starts to date, but was impressive in the way he dealt with more experienced rivals on hurdles debut. He has displayed speed but also battling ability, while beating better opponents than stablemate Shishkin, and should stay this trip stoutly. He makes strong appeal at around 8/1 and can be selected each way.
If lining up, BEACON EDGE has been impressive in two hurdle starts to date and could surprise a few at 33/1.
Should the sun come out and things dry up.
The horse that brings the best form into the race in my eyes is Gordon Elliott’s ABACADABRAS. He has displayed a high cruising speed in his four races this season and has only found Envoi Allen too good. That rival had the advantage of racing position when they met and had Abacadabras been closer to the pace, he could have given his stablemate a real fright. His jumping can at times be iffy, but he tends to be flat and quick over his hurdles. In going down to Envoi Allen he also proved that he could battle. As a horse with a quick action he is likely better on good ground and in that (unlikely) eventuality odds of 11/2 look value with the front two in the market largely priced up on potential.
EDWARDSTONE looks a great each way play at around 20/1. With a strong pace ensured, he can finish strongly and could easily run into a place.
With plenty of going change still likely, it’s now best to wait until the day before having a bet.
Now, as I finally draw breath….
Who do you fancy for the Supreme? Please feel free to leave a comment below.
Thanks for reading.
Ed Culham
Subscribe to Ed Culham's Cheltenham Festival Special
Ed Culham is one of our Festival specialists. He’s a top class Tipster, focusing on Weekends and Festivals, while delivering fantastic amounts of profit for his followers. His write ups are phenomenal, and he shows that his knowledge of the sport is out of this world at every opportunity.
Find out more below!
Hi Ed.
Many thanks for aa very comprehensive analysis of the Supreme.
For what it’s worth I backed Shishkin at big odds, but have subsequently laid back at these low odds. I’m entirely in your camp and think he’s poor value and your reasons give me comfort that I have done the right thing.
Agree that there’s little to be gained by betting before Monday week or on the day, as the going is all important. After such a long wet winter, the going surely will be soft.
Best wishes Des Magrath.
Hi Des,
Thanks for commenting.
I would always be wary of a horse that hasn’t had to battle against inferior opposition the last twice. We don’t know what he will find off the bridle when really challenged, as he will be in the Supreme. I don’t know what odds you had him at previously, but he’s currently nearly the price Douvan was when winning a much weaker edition of the race, so he definitely doesn’t represent value in my mind!
All the best for Cheltenham.
Ed Culham