Bet Victor Gold Cup Preview
Ed CulhamYou are here: Home /
Cheltenham November Meeting
15th – 17th November 2019
Saturday 16th November
BetVictor Gold Cup Handicap Chase (Grade 3) (4 year old+)
The feature race of the meeting and an often hugely competitive handicap, although the great Martin Pipe might be forgiven for thinking otherwise as he won the race no fewer than eight times. On three of those occasions Tony McCoy was in the saddle, with the 20 time Champion Jockey completing his 4th and final win in the race on Jonjo O’Neill’s Exotic Dancer in 2006.
Inaugurated in 1960, this race has featured some top-drawer chasers, including most notably in recent times, 2008 winner Imperial Commander. He went on to win the Ryanair Chase at the Festival in the same season, before claiming a stellar Gold Cup in 2009 that had both Kauto Star and Denman in the line-up.
This is a race well worth taking note of with March in mind, with the form being upheld well in many of the Festival races. In the last ten years, of the horses placed (finished 1st – 3rd in this case), 21 have gone on to run at the Festival. Of those runners, 3 triumphed come March (a 14% win rate), with wins in the Gold Cup, Ryanair and Grand Annual. Long Run’s 3rd in this race in 2010 is perhaps the pick as he went on to land the Gold Cup just two starts later. There were also 10 placed horses at the Festival that had finished in the first three in this contest (yielding an impressive 62% strike rate when staking each way if also including the 3 winners). Most frequently runners from this race have stuck to the same trip, running in the Ryanair over 2 miles 4 furlongs (9 runs), the B&A Plate was the next most frequently contested (7 runs), with the Gold Cup, Ultima Handicap, Coral Cup, Grand Annual and JLT all having a single runner respectively. Saturday’s running will certainly provide much food for thought then.
Those good performances at the Festival underline the importance of having Cheltenham form, which is of course is no less required in this contest. While this remains one of the most challenging handicap puzzles to solve over the course of a season, there are several trends that come to light when looking into the last ten renewals. Here they are below.
Trends – last 10 years
8/10 Had run in a chase over the Old Course at Cheltenham before
7/10 Had contested between 1 and 10 chases in their career to date
7/10 Winners were aged 7 or younger (Of the others: 1 – 8 year old winner and 2 – 9 year old winners)
6/10 Winners had had a run before coming into the race. Of those, 5/6 ran over more or less the same trip of 2 mile 4 furlongs
6/10 Had won a Graded chase in the past (either novice or handicap)
6/10 Winners were rated between 140 – 150
5/10 Had won a chase at Cheltenham (Old and New Courses) before
4/10 Were making their seasonal reappearance
Only 3/10 winners have returned at odds of more than 10/1
There has been only 1 winning favourite in the last 10 years (Tranquil Sea 11/2, 2009)
Runners
Siruh Du Lac – 5/1 Generally*
Hugely progressive last season, winning four in a row over fences, going up 27lbs in the weights in the process. Likes Cheltenham (2/2 over fences here) and has won on the back of a lay-off but needs another personal best now.
Siruh Du Lac produced one of the striking performances of the Festival last season, when winning the Brown & Advisory Plate. Throughout the race Lizzie Kelly gave this horse a bold sight from the front of the field, and he came up for her at every occasion, flying the last before gamely toughing it out up the hill to repel all rivals. When winning in March this horse had three of Saturday’s rivals, Spiritofthegames, Eamon An Cnoic and Splash Of Ginge in behind.
The fact that this horse was able to lead a field that wasn’t short of confirmed front runners, including Splash Of Ginge, in the Plate and then to be able to maintain his run to the line was mightily impressive. Clearly Siruh Du Lac stays strongly at this trip of 2 miles 4 furlongs, and could make this into a serious test on what is likely to be bottomless ground. Such conditions might not suit this horse though, as while he has won on soft his only defeat in his last 7 starts came on heavy.
It’s very hard to pick holes in such a consistent performer, who will likely again show his best at Cheltenham. That said, on a new mark of 150 and making his seasonal reappearance he will need to be at his very best to take this prize. On balance and at the prices, I would rather pass him over this time.
Slate House – 5/1
A forgotten horse last season as he struggled to reignite the spark he had showed in his early novice hurdle career. Had a second wind operation in the spring and returned with a bang to register his first chase win over course and distance in October.
On that recent evidence he looks back to his best as he jumped and travelled supremely well for Robbie Power, relishing the heavy going. Whether he beat anything much remains to be seen, with some of the opposition that had contested handicaps being ranked in the low 130s. Now pitched into handicaps for the first time, it is tricky to gauge whether he is well in on a mark of 147. This certainly is a far harder race, will demand an improved effort and put more pressure on his jumping, but he has always been touted as a Graded class horse and if truly back to those levels could prove too good for his opposition.
The fact that you have to look two years back into Slate House’s form book to uncover any meaningful performances is certainly a worry. His latest wind operation could have worked the oracle, but for me he still isn’t a horse to trust to back up his performance last time out. I’d prefer to watch him once again before I can back him with any confidence.
Spiritofthegames – 7/1
A horse that goes especially well when fresh, with 3 wins in his last 3 seasonal reappearances. Has been aimed at this race by Dan Skelton and warrants respect.
Didn’t run up to form when last seen in the Manifesto Novices Chase at Aintree in the spring, but before that was seen knocking on the door in two contests at Cheltenham. Both times he finished to good effect over 2 miles 4 furlongs, running on strongly up the hill. It should be noted though, that while running on, on both occasions he never gave impression that he would chase down the leaders.
His second run at Cheltenham came in the Plate, when he finished 3 lengths behind Siruh Du Lac. He returns to action this season on a 3lb higher mark (150) and is now 6lbs better off with that rival. That potentially could be enough to reverse the form, especially given this is his first run of the season. However, I have a feeling that this horse who has only had one success over fences, doesn’t hold many secrets from the handicapper and is the type to run well but find a few too good once again.
Us And Them – 8/1
Plenty of chase experience for a 6 year old, but didn’t enjoy much luck as a novice last season when finishing 2nd several times to the high class Le Richebourg and Duc Des Genievres. Handicap debut.
At many times last season his run style indicated that this horse required a trip beyond the 2 mile minimum. It was pleasing then, to see him turn in a smart performance on seasonal debut over 2 miles 4 furlongs at Gowran, when he lead until between the last two fences, before fading and making a bad error at the last. From that evidence it looks like this trip should suit and there could be improvement to come on his second start.
Us And Them has never fallen in nine chase starts, but can occasionally throw in a sketchy leap. In the Arkle he jumped well for the most part, but several slow jumps saw him drop to the tail of the field down the back straight. He will have to be slicker at his obstacles here, but on evidence of his Gowran run, barring the error at the last, he has improved since last spring. What was impressive was the way he made up ground from the 3rd last in the Arkle to pass five rivals in the run to the line.
With the trip to suit, heavy ground holding no fears and his jumping potentially better this season, Us And Them looks the type to play a big part in this race. What remains to be seen is whether he can adjust to handicaps on a mark of 152.
Count Meribel – 9/1
Fits the bill as a gradual improver for Nigel Twiston-Davies and also has the right profile for the race (7 year old, Cheltenham form, with a good racing weight). Chance.
Played second fiddle to the exceptional Lostintranslation recently at Carlisle, and while Count Meribel’s jumping was overshadowed by that of his giant rival he too put in a super round of steeple chasing. Mark Grant didn’t have to ask him to come up for his fences, but he made a fine shape over the obstacles when leading off the front foot. At the finish, his rider didn’t ask for everything (whip used twice), but he still stayed on stoutly up the Carlisle hill. That bodes well for a horse that has already claimed a chase win over the Old Course at Prestbury Park and over this trip too.
When winning his novice chase here last November, Count Meribel blundered seriously at the second last fence, with two challenging rivals inheriting the lead. From there winning looked an impossible task for this horse, but somehow, he managed to reorganise and stay on up the hill to just prevail. Subsequently he probably found 3 miles a stretch in the Arkle, but still looked to be in with a chance before the turn in. There can be no questioning this horse’s attitude then and his ability to handle Cheltenham’s stern jumping test.
While now 9lbs higher than his sole handicap win (137), this horse has a progressive look to him. He should also be suited by the strong pace, likely to be set by Siruh Du Lac and Splash Of Ginge, as he often assumes a position in running just behind the leaders. Very testing ground might be a bit of a concern, but he has shown his ability to stay strongly at the trip and his jumping should hold up.
Saint Calvados – 11/1
Talented, often front running chaser, who ultimately failed in the highest company last season. Won well on reappearance and now tries two and a half miles for the first time.
Ran three weeks ago at Cheltenham when winning a 2 mile handicap off top weight in attritional conditions. That was a fine effort and he seemed to benefit from being given a more patient ride, held up in midfield this time as oppose to his usual front running style. It looked like the line came just in time for Saint Calvados as Vaniteux closed at the finish. Conditions are likely to be similar on Saturday after the recent heavy rainfall and while they hold no issue for Harry Whittington’s runner an extra half a mile on this ground could prove too much, especially considering this will be his first attempt at the trip.
Besides that, he is now 4lbs higher than his recent win and this looks a deeper contest. Best to take him on in these circumstances.
Springtown Lake – 12/1
Philip Hobbs’s runner could be on a dangerous mark here, particularly with the recent rain doing him a favour. Plenty of stamina and could pick up the pieces if they go too fast.
Made his seasonal reappearance in the Bet365 Gold Cup at Ascot two weeks ago, when plodding on for 7th. Seemingly he travelled well in midfield and his jumping was accurate. However, he looked outpaced when the leading group quickened off the home turn and while staying on was passed by several rivals in the run to the last fence. That was over 3 miles, so it is questionable whether a drop back to 2m 4f will do him any favours. One thing this horse does relish though are testing conditions, while also having the capacity to stay 3 miles stoutly. That could prove invaluable should the leaders go too hard from the front here.
Springtown Lake also has experience of Cheltenham having contested the Close Brothers Novices’ Chase at the Festival, when finishing 5th, albeit beaten 27 lengths. A bad error at the 3rd last knocked him back in the field, before he stayed on again at the finish.
At Ascot, this horse looked like he may well have needed the run and can strip fitter for that. Now on a mark of 137, 4lbs lower than his Cheltenham run and one he has defied before, he looks like an interesting runner lurking lower down the weights.
Guitar Pete – 14/1
Looked better than ever when winning a Listed chase at Weatherby recently and has experience of this race (twice contested – 3rd last year). 4lbs higher than last year though and work to do.
When winning at Weatherby, Guitar Pete had three of Saturday’s potential rivals in behind him (Happy Diva, Demi Sang and Splash Of Ginge). He stayed on well up the run in on easy ground at the Yorkshire course and always looked to be holding runner up Happy Diva. That horse now receives a 5lbs swing with Guitar Pete, but I would have thought the Nicky Richards’ trained runner might have enough improvement to come to confirm the form here. Nicky Richards has twice before used the same Weatherby race as a warm-up for the BetVictor and this seasons’ run was arguably his best yet.
Handles plenty of the factors that make this race so difficult to win, including having form on testing ground. Still needs to be better than ever to go two better than last year.
Eamon An Cnoic – 16/1
Ran a fine race in last year’s renewal, when looking like the winner between the last two fences. Doesn’t stay this trip as strongly as some though, which poses serious questions given the ground.
Has had several decent spins around Cheltenham over 2 miles 4 furlongs and one over 3 miles. While he has won chases before over the shorter of those distances, they were both small field (3 and 6 runners) novice affairs. It seems that the demands of Cheltenham, in races that are usually strongly run put a bit too much emphasis on stamina for this horse’s liking. I see his lack of sound staying ability to be a huge weakness in this contest and given he is also 3lbs higher in the weights than when running last year, he is readily passed over.
Magic Saint – 16/1
Paul Nicholls has won this race twice with two comparatively inexperienced chasers (Al Ferof and Caid Du Berlais), but this French recruit has had a fair few runs over fences now. Largely disappointing last season, with hopes this campaign seemingly pinned on a summer wind operation.
Won once last season over a sharp 2 miles at Warwick on good ground. Has had a run over the New Course at Cheltenham, but whether he wants this kind of trip or ground remains to be seen. He might be one who will improve for the run and is best watched here.
Others
Happy Diva is a fine mare who more often than not runs her race but has had plenty of opportunities in these sorts of races and looks weighted to her best.
Highway One O One likes to race prominently but will have his work cut out trying to dominate Siruh Du Lac at the head of affairs. Heavy ground over this trip also holds concerns.
Venetia William’s Belami Des Pictons goes well on heavy ground and has stamina in abundance. He has only run once in two years though, so can only be watched here.
The handicapper has given 11 year old Cheltenham veteran Splash Of Ginge a chance with a mark of 133, 1lb less than when he won this race in 2017. He hasn’t won since then though and it would be surprising were he not to find a few younger horses too good.
Brelan D’As runs for Paul Nicholls but looked to be beginning to struggle when pulling up in the race won by Saint Calvados here in October.
The others, Royal Village, Warthog, Mercian Price, Dell Oro and Demi Sang look outclassed and have it all to do.
*Prices correct at the time of writing
Verdict
With Friday’s card succumbing to the weather and reports of waterlogging down the back straight we can only hope that racing on Saturday goes ahead as planned. What it will mean is the going, already soft on Thursday, will be virtually bottomless and 2 miles 4 furlongs round the Old Course could turn into a real slog. With that in mind it seems sensible to look for runners with confirmed stamina and a liking for ease in the ground. I have also chosen to err away from out and out front runners, as there are a few in here which could lead to an overly strong pace. Horses with a run already under their belt may also have an advantage, as we saw recently when Nigel Twiston-Davies’ Ballyoptic won the Charlie Hall on soft ground. As it happens, it is another horse trained by the same trainer that I am keen on here in the shape of COUNT MERIBEL who put in an impressive display of jumping when chasing home Lostintranslation at Carlisle recently. Another who has had a run and will certainly appreciate conditions is SPRINGTOWN LAKE and could be staying on well when others have cried enough. Such conditions will make lumping a big weight around the Old Course a tough ask, but Slate House, Siruh Du Lac, Spiritofthegames and Us And Them could easily be up to the task. The last mentioned gets the nod to fill out 3rd place after a good reappearance in Graded company at Gowran when trying 2 miles 4 furlongs for the first time, so there could be improvement to come. Siruh Du Lac could find this harder than when winning last year.
1 – COUNT MERIBEL
2 – SPRINGTOWN LAKE
3 – US AND THEM
4 – SIRUH DU LAC
Count Meribel 0.5 points each way @ 10/1 – Coral, Ladbrokes (4 places, 1/4)
Springtown Lake 0.5 points each way @ 12/1 – Sky Bet, Paddy Power, Betfair (5 places, 1/5)
Ed Culham
Subscribe to Ed's services
Ed Culham runs a Weekend-only and a Festival-only package, as well as a combined one. The results that he has produced since he has been with us are fantastic, check them out!