York Ebor Review

and eye-catchers

You are here: Home / York Ebor Review + Eye-catchers


 Ed Culham has reviewed the York and given his eye-catchers from the week. Once again top work from Ed and a very enjoyable read. He smashed the Ebor to bits with his free blogs which included 16/1 winner Mustajeer in the York Ebor.

Keep your eyes peeled for future race previews.

York Ebor Festival Review 21st – 24th August

Day 1 – Wednesday 21 st August
Going: Good

Tattersalls Acomb Stakes (Group 3) (2 year old) 7 furlongs
1 st – Valdermoro
2 nd – Harpocrates
3 rd – Ropey Guest
9 ran
Yorkshire Gold and Harpocrates cut out the early running at a moderate tempo, with Valdermoro
vying for third against the rail. The complexion of the race changed as Harpocrates travelled well and
put a few lengths between himself and his pursuers 4 furlongs out. With the others working hard in
behind he still had a 2 length lead going inside the final furlong. Harpocrates looked to have the
contest in safe keeping but tied up towards the finish and was worn down by Valdermoro on the
line.
Harpocrates benefitted from first time blinkers and was unlucky not to win. If anything, he perhaps
travelled too exuberantly, which told at the line. Probably not going to make waves in higher class
races but can run well again kept to this level.
The winner, Valdermoro, saw out the trip better than most and had the speed to close down
Harpocrates late on. He looks a horse to follow, especially on fast ground and a step up in trip would
by looks of things be no disadvantage.
There were several disappointments in behind, including well backed favourite Persuasion, who
never threatened to get involved. Joseph O’Brien’s Vitalogy was another who was well fancied. He
stuck on late but looked inexperienced in this field upped in class from maiden company and should
do more next time.

Eyecatcher
Ropey Guest ran on well from the rear of the field, but so too did the more lightly raced MORISCO.
He showed his inexperience leaving the stalls as he lost several lengths, while he was also keen when
he had caught up with the field. With this being his third run there could be lots more to come from
this big son of Requinto.
No current future entries.

Sky Bet Great Voltigeur Stakes (Group 2) (3 year old – Colts & Geldings) 1 mile 4 furlongs
1 st – Logician
2 nd – Constantinople
3 rd – Norway
5 ran

Norway was briskly away, assuming pace setting duties for his more favoured stablemate
Constantinople, who was switched off out the back. Jalmoud was keen in 2 nd , with Logician running
3 rd early on. Norway and Jalmoud went further clear down the back straight, with the other three
runners opting to bide their time. The pace was still a reasonably strong one, passing 7 furlongs and
turning the bend. The field then closed 3 furlongs from home, with the two main protagonists,
Logician and Constantinople, coming through between runners. Initially Ryan Moore looked to be
going the better, but Dettori got first run on Logician and the grey looked the more willing
companion as he only had to be pushed out to score.
This must rank as a very smart performance from the son of Frankel, who took his record to 4/4 and
looked at ease on his first outing in Group company. There was a slight moment of concern 3
furlongs out as he came under pressure, but Dettori cleverly used his staying prowess to his
advantage when kicking for home first. A potential Leger bid looks on the cards and frighteningly for
his rivals he might prove even better over 1 mile 6.
Constantinople looked more at home at York than last time out at Goodwood but seemed one paced
when asked to quicken by Moore. Needs a real test of stamina to be seen at his best.

Eyecatcher
The front two were a class apart, but NORWAY ran a big race for 3 rd , especially when setting such a
strong gallop. A 9 length defeat at the hands of Logician arguably ranks as one of his best
performances to date and eased slightly in grade he would be interesting.
Next entries: St Leger (Doncaster 14 th September), Group 3 Kilternan Stakes (Leopardstown 14 th
September)

Juddmonte International (Group 1) (3 year old+) 1 mile 2 ½ furlongs
1 st – Japan
2 nd – Crystal Ocean
3 rd – Elarqam
9 ran
Race preview predicted order: Crystal Ocean (2 nd )*, King Of Comedy (4 th ), Japan (1 st ), Cheval Grand
(8 th )
*actual finishing position

Circus Maximus was quickly away from the stalls, going forward on the outside to take the lead with
Crystal Ocean reined back to assume position behind him. Elarqam sat third against the rail with
Japan out wider. King Of Comedy raced keenly behind runners. The pace was an even one, with
about 8 lengths first to last at half-way. Circus Maximus tried to quicken off the front end 4 furlongs
out, but Crystal Ocean cruised up alongside as the other runners also came under pressure behind.
Crystal Ocean hit the front 2 furlongs out, while chased by Japan and King Of Comedy running on out
wide. Going inside the furlong, Japan put his nose ahead, only for the ever game Crystal Ocean to
respond, but Japan was back in front when it mattered to record a famous scalp.

Crystal Ocean gave his all again, but his customary turn of foot wasn’t in evidence at York. There are
probably several reasons for this, including 1 mile 2 furlongs on good ground not being optimum, but
more likely he may still have been feeling the effects of his bruising encounter with Enable in the
King George. I must admit, despite these factors I still thought he would have the quality to account
for his rivals, so for him to be beaten was a disappointment.
Take nothing away from Japan though, who now has really shown his hand as perhaps the best of
the 3 year old crop. In my preview I placed him 3 rd , because I thought he might find 1 mile 2 furlongs
too sharp, having not run over that trip since his disappointment in the Dante. I clearly read too
much into that run and wasn’t charitable enough to the horse when it was said he had had a set
back in May before his Derby preparation. This performance at York was something really special.
King Of Comedy displayed inexperience when pulling hard early on and despite looking like he might
come with a telling run on the outside entering the last furlong, his challenge ultimately petered out.
Without his antics early on he surely would have finished closer and probably is still a horse for 10
furlongs. He should get better with racing.

Eyecatcher
ELARQAM surprised me with a mighty run to finish 3 rd and was slightly unfortunate to get boxed in
when looking for a way past Japan and Crystal Ocean. I must admit this was a horse I wrote off
slightly after a poor season last year and I didn’t see his performances this year transferring well at
the highest level. That wasn’t the case at York on Wednesday. He looks to have his confidence back
and is steadily progressive again.
Next entry: Champions Stakes (Ascot October 19 th ).

Day 2 – Thursday 22 nd August
Going: Good (Good-Firm in places)
Sky Bet Lowther Stakes (Group 2) (2 year old – Fillies) 6 furlongs
1st – Living In The Past
2 nd – Liberty Beach
3 rd – Good Vibes
10 ran

Runners got away to a level break. Living In The Past and Nasaiym came forward to race prominently
after the first furlong. Living In The Past put her long stride to good use and was travelling best
passing halfway with only Liberty Beach in the chasing pack not under maximum pressure. Danny
Tudhope was not for passing and although Liberty Beach ran on well to press Living In The Past with
Good Vibes following, it was too late.
This was a good performance from Living In The Past as she reversed form last time out with Under
The Stars (4 th ). She seemed to appreciate being able to dominate from the front.
Liberty Beach ran well on her first try at 6 furlongs but didn’t have the sustained turn of foot over
the longer distance to run down her rival. She can run better over 6 furlongs with more experience.

Good Vibes was one of few closers from the back of the field, so her effort can be upgraded.

Eyecatcher
WEJDAN travelled reasonably well but was outpaced at a crucial time, before running on again. That
was only his second start and there could be more to come. Looks a candidate for 7 furlongs.
Next entry: Cheveley Park Stakes (Newmarket 28 th September)

Darley Yorkshire Oaks (Group 1) (3 year old+ Fillies & Mares) 1 mile 4 furlongs
1 st – Enable
2 nd – Magical
3 rd – Lah Ti Dar
4 ran
Race preview predicted order: ENABLE, MAGICAL, Anapurna (didn’t line up)

Enable was very quickly into stride and led at a sharp clip. Stablemate Lah Ti Dar followed with
Magical in 3 rd position and South Sea Pearl at the rear. Enable remained about 2 lengths clear at the
top of the home straight and then Magical and Lah Ti Dar closed to the leader’s quarters. Dettori
waited for Moore to get to work on Magical, before setting Enable alight 2 furlongs from home. She
responded and asserted her lead over her old rival winning by nearly 3 lengths at the line.
This was a superb performance from a superb race mare, but in truth the result never looked in
doubt once Dettori was allowed to go to the front leaving the stalls. In the straight she showed that
she has improved with racing this season, easily coming clear of Magical who had come within a
length of beating her in the Eclipse at Sandown. I couldn’t see any other result, with Enable being
such a consistent mare. She will be greatly missed by all racegoers on these shores.
Magical looked always booked for 2 nd , but Ryan Moore may regret not putting more pressure on
Enable early on. She never truly got up alongside her rival and was well beaten at the finish.
With Anapurna not turning up at York, Lah Ti Dar deputised and secured 3 rd , but was beaten some 12
lengths by the front two. She didn’t get the better of South Sea Pearl (SP 100/1) by much and so
following a close 3 rd to Coronet in France it can’t be viewed as a great run.

Eyecatcher
Nothing much to catch the eye except the magnificent ENABLE who secured her 10 th Group 1 success
and was much too good.
Next entry: All eyes now turn to her bid to sign off her career in ultimate glory with a third straight
Arc de Triomphe (6 th October)

Day 3 – Friday 23 rd August
Going: Good-Firm (Good in places)
Weatherbys Hamilton Lonsdale Cup Stakes (Group 2) (3 year old+) 2 miles ½ furlong

1 st – Stradivarius
2 nd – Dee Ex Bee
3 rd – Il Paradiso
4 ran

Dee Ex Bee when on into an early lead and was tracked closely by Il Paradiso. There was 4 lengths
back to Stradivarius and a further length to Falcon Eight at the tail. Runners closed up, with about 5
lengths first to last going down the back straight. Going inside 7 furlongs there was little change in
the running. Dee Ex Bee tried to inject some pace rounding the home turn and had 2 lengths in hand
over Il Paradiso passing the half mile point. Stradivarius tracked the front two, who were both under
pressure and locked together passing the 2 pole. He then quickly mastered those rivals with a turn of
foot in the last furlong as he cosily went on to score by just over a length.
Another £1 million stayers’ bonus for Stradivarius who carries all before him in the staying division.
He always finds a way to win and the signs were ominous for the front two as he slip-streamed them
entering the last two furlongs. When pulled out by Dettori to deliver his challenge the crowd were
treated to the type of gutsy performance that has made Stradivarius such a favourite.
Dee Ex Bee was beaten for a third time by a horse who has become his nemesis this season. He did
little wrong on the front end, but just lacks the turn of foot that makes Stradivarius such a stand out
performer.

Eyecatcher
IL PARADISO looked for more than a moment to be the greatest threat to Stradivarius in the straight
as he headed long time leader Dee Ex Bee, only to just lose out on 2 nd as that rival fought back on the
line. He was beaten only 1 ¼ lengths, a remarkably good performance from a horse who had only
won a handicap and maiden previously.
Next entries: St Leger (14 th September) and Irish St Leger (15 th September)

Al Basti Equiworld Dubai Gimcrack Stakes (Group 2) (2 year old – Colts & Geldings) 6 furlongs
1 st – Threat
2 nd – Lord Of The Lodge
3 rd Repartee
12 ran

A tightly bunched field to start, as Repartee, Lord Of The Lodge and Abstemious were soon pressing
to the front. Iffraaz was pushed along from halfway suggesting that the pace was a strong one. Lord
Of The Lodge still had the lead passing 2 furlongs as the field fanned out across the track. Threat was
brought through and took a while to get going, but readily kicked away in the last half furlong to
score by over a length.
Threat carried the best form into the race, after close 2nds in Group 2 company the last twice at
Ascot and Goodwood. He made no mistake this time and looked superior to his rivals, who struggled

to maintain their challenge when the pace of the race increased. Looks to be consistently on the
improve and should benefit from getting his head in front in one of these contests.
Lord Of The Lodge improved dramatically after being dropped back to a novice race last time out. He
travelled better than almost everything in the race but was outpaced by a sharper rival toward the
finish. Keeping on well at the line he could be a candidate for a step up in trip.
Repartee continued his progression on his third start here, after a close 4 th in a Listed contest the
time before.

Eyecatcher
A horse who closed well from the rear after getting caught on the heals of rivals as the pace
quickened was MALOTRU. No horse made up more ground in the last furlong, as he claimed 3 places
and finished to good effect to claim 4 th . Already a Group winner, with speed but also clearly staying
ability, 7 furlongs and more time to get into the race may see him to better effect. One to keep on
side next time.
Next entry: Champagne Stakes (Doncaster 14 th September)

Coolmore Nunthorpe Stakes (Group 1) (2 year old+) 5 furlongs
1 st – Battaash
2 nd – Soldier’s Call
3 rd – So Perfect
11 ran

Race preview predicted order: Mabs Cross (4 th ), Ten Sovereigns (6 th ), Battaash (1 st ), Garrus (11 th )
Ornate burst out of the gates to lead, followed by Soldier’s Call and Battaash. Favourite Ten
Sovereigns was bustled along to go the early pace, which was a frenetic one. Battaash breezed
through to lead at halfway as Jim Crowley began to crouch lower in the saddle. With everything else
flat to the boards in behind he went further clear, his closest challenger still Soldier’s Call, with Ten
Sovereigns and Mabs Cross both making heavy weather of closing the gap. Battaash skipped away by
4 lengths and maintained it to the line.
After two anti climaxes before in this race, Battaash certainly proclaimed his place at the top of the
sprinting tree as he tore apart the field in devastating fashion, smashing the course record in the
process. In my preview I had thought that the early competition for the lead, with Ornate and
Soldier’s Call prominent as expected, might hinder Battaash’s chances, especially with some stronger
stayers in the field. Here Charlie Hill’s most prized runner showed his versatility, perhaps helped by
the fast ground that allowed him to show his true speed. I had been sceptical about Battaash’s
ability to put it together at certain tracks like York, but he proved me wrong in resounding style, as
speed really rose to the fore.
Having been up with the pace for so long, indeed early on he had been ahead of Battaash, Soldier’s
Call did brilliantly to stick it out for 2 nd . He was never going to be able to live with the cruising speed
of Battaash when off the bridle. His run exhibited the form of both the Sapphire Stakes and King’s

Stand, where he had finished closer to Battaash. Cemented his reputation as one of the best of his

age group over the flying five.
So Perfect has been threatening to place in a big race for a while now and it was a great
performance from the filly, who pipped her fellow female Mabs Cross to 3 rd when staying on
approaching the line.
Mabs Cross didn’t find her late change of gear that she often does and her run didn’t match the level
of form that she showed in this contest last year.
I had thought that Ten Sovereigns would get outpaced before staying on late, but I hadn’t envisaged
him to be so slowly away and playing catch up early on. He did get back into the race, but such small
errors highlight the difference in pace between 5 and 6 furlong contests.

Eyecatcher
SO PERFECT has run three solid races in Group 1 company of late and this ferocious pace seemed to
suit her as she dropped back to 5 furlongs for the first time this season. She stayed on impressively
and took places off Mabs Cross and Ten Sovereigns towards the finish. A slight ease in class could
see her in the winners’ enclosure soon.
Next entry: Sprint Cup Stakes (Haydock 7 th September)

Day 4 – Saturday 24 th August
Going: Good-Firm
Sky Bet And Symphony Group Strensall Stakes (Group 3) (3 year old+) 1 mile 1 furlong
1st – Zaaki
2 nd – Bangkok
3 rd – Space Traveller
6 ran

Forest Ranger led early, chased by Wissahickon and Zaaki in third. With 5 furlongs to run Bangkok
made a minor mid-race move around runners to press for second position. From 3 furlongs out the
race developed into a bit of a sprint as Bangkok and Wissahickon went at it. Zaaki was produced
between runners and drew alongside Bangkok before gradually asserting in the last half furlong.
Zaaki appreciated the step back up in trip after finding 7 furlongs too sharp at Goodwood last time. It
was slightly surprising he had the staying ability to conquer Bangkok late on, but take nothing away
from the son of Leroidesanimeaux who deserved his victory. The fact that there were only 3 lengths
between all runners at the line will testify that this was a closely fought contest, but perhaps not one
to delve too deeply into as regards future form.

Eyecatcher
SPACE TRAVELLER kept on well on his first start beyond 7 furlongs. There certainly should be
improvement to come at this trip.

Next entries: Park Stakes (Doncaster 14 th September), Clipper Logistics Boomerang Stakes
(Leopardstown 14 th September)

Sky Bet City Of York Stakes (Group 2) (3 year old+) 7 furlongs
1st – Shine So Bright
2 nd – Laurens
3 rd – Cape Byron
9 ran

Shine So Bright was quickly away, with Laurens and Cape Byron chasing up what was a brisk early
gallop. 4 furlongs out, Shine So Bright had a 2 length lead and the situation was the same going
inside the final two furlongs. Laurens began to close with Cape Byron just behind inside the last
furlong, with the first mentioned wearing away at the leader until there was nothing to split them at
the line. They flashed past the winning post virtually together with Shine So Bright edging the verdict
by a nose.
A fine front running performance by Shine So Bright who hadn’t run since finishing 6 th in the 2000
Gunieas. He looked a true 7 furlong horse here, appreciated the drop back in trip and showed speed
early in the race as well as grit to hang on at the finish.
This was a strongly run contest with nothing able to get into the race from the rear of the field.
Despite the strong pace Laurens may have found this trip a touch on the sharp side, with it being her
first run over 7 furlongs since her 2 year old days.
Cape Byron, back over 7 furlongs looked better than when last seen in the July Cup and can resume
his progress over this trip.
The fact that the front three, who shared the early lead, came home in the places after such a strong
early gallop, suggests this is form that should be followed.

Eyecatcher
Nothing obviously eye-catching with most runners seeming to run their race.

Sky Bet Ebor Handicap (Class 2) (4 year old+) 1 mile 6 furlongs
1 st – Mustajeer
2 nd – Red Galileo
3 rd – Desert Skyline
4 th – Raymond Tusk
5 th – Barsanti
22 ran

Race preview predicted order: MUSTAJEER, Royal Line (didn’t line up), Baghdad (17 th ), Mekong
(10 th ), Raheen House (9 th )

The field broke evenly with the exception of Making Miracles who missed the kick and was pushed
along some 5 lengths adrift. After 2 furlongs most of the field were gathered on the rails, where
Withhold and Dramatic Queen cut out the running. Ben Vrackie cut over from a wide position to
head the pack 3 furlongs in, leaving Weekender isolated, but he too soon moved across to vie for 3 rd
place. Going inside the mile, Mustajeer was positioned in mid-field against the rails, with Red Galileo
to his outside. Desert Skyline was further back, posted wider in the field, with Raymond Tusk and
Barsanti near the back of the pack. Entering the top of the straight the field fanned out, and inside
the final two furlongs True Self put it up to long time leader Ben Vrackie. Mustajeer was brought
through in the middle of the course, while Red Galileo ploughed a route up the stands rail. In the last
half furlong Mustajeer mastered True Self and held off several late challenges to grab the £600,000
first prize, as he prevailed by ¾ length at the line.
A thrilling race and one where I was equally thrilled to get the winner, tipped up early at odds of
16/1. I had written in my race preview that I thought Mustajeer could improve on his 4 th placed finish
in the Ebor of last season. His preparation looked to be more challenging this campaign, but he had
acquitted himself well in Group company, so it was a surprise to see him line up on the same mark as
last year. On quick ground he showed that he can quicken, and when Colin Keane asked him to chase
down True Self he was certain to see the trip out well to the line. It’s a shame we won’t be seeing
more of this horse on UK or Irish soil as he heads Down Under to continue his racing career, with a
shot at the Melbourne Cup likely.
Red Galileo has been running well this season and followed up on a strong Northumberland Plate
run as he finished strongly for 2 nd . With a mark of 109 he doesn’t look to have too much room for
manoeuvre though.
Desert Skyline is now without a win in nearly 2 years and 15 starts, but this was his best run for quite
a while. He was a little unlucky also when entering the final furlong as he couldn’t find daylight
between runners at a crucial stage. Not getting much help from the handicapper (marks have varied
from 112 – 107 since his last win), and he may have to wait a bit longer before another victory
comes his way.
Barsanti finished with a real rattle in first time blinkers and still looks to have potential off this mark.
With the first five finishers coming from the mid-rear of the field, this was a strongly run contest, so
look out for horses who maintained their position near the front longer than others with a view to
next time.

Eyecatcher
2 furlongs out by far the best travelling horse was RAYMOND TUSK, who was well on the bridle but
caught behind a wall of runners. When getting the splits, he cut through the field incisively, finishing
better than anything to claim 4 th . With more luck in running he would have been even closer and
possibly would have challenged Mustajeer. That was Raymond Tusk’s first handicap start after
running in some seriously hot Group races this season. If his mark (111) doesn’t take too much of a
hit, he could be one to follow in high quality handicaps, perhaps even this race next year.

Ed Culham

 

Want FREE Horse Racing tips every day from our team of Professional Tipsters?

28 day trials are still available

We still have places left for our £2.99 trials with our Tipsters.

At the time of writing, a 28 day trial with CD Racing would’ve netted you over £386 to £10 stakes. His form over the past month has been nothing short of incredible.

In Form Tipster (August)

 

 

In Form Tipster (August):
Cotswold Racing

Key stats:

Points profit:
ROI %:

32.00
30.00%

Find out more

Quick stat – ROI

Cotswold:
Apollo:
Lombard:
Matrix:
Match Day:
9.48
10.29%
6.07%
7.45%
15.35%

Grab a Trial

Quick stat – Monthly profit

Cotswold:
Apollo:
Lombard:
Matrix:
Match Day:
£4
£48
£19
£49
N/A

To £10 stakes

Grab a Trial

Translate

Want A Free Horse Racing Tip Everyday?

Enter your email address and you will receive a free tip every day. Simple as that!

Thankyou for subscribing!

Want A Free Horse Racing Tip Everyday?

Enter your email address and you will receive a free tip every day. Simple as that!

Thankyou for subscribing!

Pin It on Pinterest