York Musidora and Dante Race Preview
You are here: Home /
First of all I would like to credit Ed Culham who is going to be working with Tipsters Empire and JPW Racing Tipster over the flat season, by providing relevant content to our readers. I was approached by Ed who has a big interest in Horse Racing and writing about the sport of kings. After a few emails exchanged and some tester blogs, I thought the content he provides is excellent and worthwhile to our followers.
Enjoy the read and any comments are welcome.
York
A feast of racing action on the Knavesmire awaits this week as the Dante Festival comes to York. Aside from many compelling handicaps, Listed and Group races there are two key trials likely to complete the Oaks and Derby classic pictures, before eyes turn to Epsom in little over two weeks time.
Unlike Chester and Lingfield that have recently hosted trials, the course here does not necessarily provide a unique test for these young horses. Runners have two sweeping left-handed turns to negotiate before heading down York’s famously long, wide home straight. This doesn’t mean that the trials are of any lesser quality however, with in recent years winners such as The Fugue, Golden Horn and Roaring Lion gracing these contests.
Wednesday is the turn of the fillies in the Musidora Stakes, while the colts run the following day in the Group 2 Dante Stakes.
Musidora Stakes (Group 3) 1 mile 2 ½ furlongs
Wednesday 15th May – 3:35
Will it be another Musidora for John Gosden? The master trainer has notched 5 of the last 10 renewals and 3 in the last 5 years. In contrast to other recent trials this is a race Aidan O’Brien is yet to win, and seemingly not one he targets with only 5 runners in the last 10 years.
As might be expected, this year’s renewal is filled with unexposed types with only three fillies from the ten strong field having run more than 3 times. Sparkle Roll heads the market having warmed up for this by winning the same Sandown novice event that last year’s winner Give And Take also ran in. The Gosden runner evidently has a bit of ability judged on that performance and could take the beating here. However, in the latter stages at Sandown she looked to have a slightly awkward head carriage, so it remains to be seen what her resolve will be if truly challenged.
John Gosden also fields Entitle, who many people’s eyes will be on with her being the half sister to superstar Enable. She has only won a Lingfield novice event but looks an attractive filly who is likely to relish the step up in distance.
Frankellina represents William Haggas, who won this last year. This filly could be open to any amount of improvement on what will be only her second start. She showed her willing in knuckling down to win her Yarmouth maiden and it will be interesting to see how she has developed from 2 to 3, as she didn’t look as well put together as some others in here, when seen out last season.
Several runners bring 2 year old Group placed form into the race, and the outsiders in the betting Blue Gardenia and I’ll Have Another both have Listed contests to their name. However, with each having had 5 starts you would expect something to improve past them. Nearer the head of the market Ralph Beckett’s Sand Share looks a likely type having finished 3rd in the May Hill Stakes at Doncaster last season. That said, her next start in a Deauville Group 3, where she was headed and outbattled towards the finish, raises questions about her stepping up in trip to 10 furlongs.
Godolphin’s Swift Rose, who was a neck away from landing a Group 3 in Meydan is another unlikely to be suited by the extra distance. The other royal blue runner, DUBAI BLUE is interesting. Another to have only a Lingfield novice win to her name, where despite running freely, she still had enough to lengthen away well towards the finish. She looked a nice, well developed filly who could improve for the trip if settling into a good racing rhythm. At a general price of 12/1 she looks value among the lesser exposed runners.
Dante Stakes (Group 2) 1 mile 2 ½ furlongs
Thursday 16th May – 3:00pm
Having been pulled from the 2000 Guineas this is likely to mark the much anticipated reappearance of Too Darn Hot. In 2015, Golden Horn used this as a stepping stone to his Derby triumph and Too Darn Hot looks set to follow suit here. John Gosden’s colt was juvenile of the season last year, winning three Group races culminating in a comprehensive victory in the Dewhurst at Newmarket. That is stand out form and he more than deserves his place at the head of the betting. It might not all be plain sailing here though; he was deemed “not ready” to run in the Guineas, having not fully recovered from a splint bone injury, but slight doubts remain about the lingering effect of that misfortune. Despite being unbeaten in four runs he is likely to be at his most vulnerable in this his reappearance, so it may be the time, if any, to take him on.
It is not beyond question that last season’s Dewhurst is only average form. So often form from that race stands up well in the 2000 Guineas and provides many other clues to the big 3 year old races, but the jury is still out this year. Dewhurst 2nd, Advertise ran a poor race in the 2000 Guineas beaten some 20 lengths. Anthony Van Dyck won the recent Lingfield Derby Trial well enough, but whether he will develop into a true Group 1 contender remains to be seen. Others to come out of the Dewhurst include Mohawk, who finished a respectable 2nd in the Dee Stakes at Chester behind stable mate Circus Maximus.
Too Darn Hot also faces some stiff opposition (probably his hardest challenge so far), in several other established Group race performers as well as a handful of lesser exposed runners. Aidan O’Brien runs the exciting colt Japan, who for some time has been viewed as the Ballydoyle’s leading representative for the Derby. In his run in the Beresford Stakes at Naas in September, Japan looked a colt who was made for middle distances, coming into his own in the last furlong to mow down runners in front of him.
It is mildly interesting that O’Brien has chosen to run him here in a race he hasn’t won since 2010. Since Cape Blanco’s victory 9 years ago, he has had nine runners in the Dante with only 3 of those placing. O’Brien’s runners to come out of the race have not tended to go on to compete at the top level, with the possible exception of 2016 2nd Deauville. It seems a surprising route for a seemingly favoured horse (for the Derby) out of Ballydoyle, but perhaps their hand was forced this time around.
Godolphin and Charlie Appleby field the impeccably bred Line Of Duty, interestingly out of Ballydoyle all-conquering sire Galileo with his dam being the 1000 Guineas winner Jaqueline Quest. He arguably brings the best form into the race, having won the Breeder’s Cup Juvenile Turf at Churchill Downs on his last outing, when he had Anthony Van Dyck nearly 7 lengths behind. That smacks of a performance more than on a par with Too Darn Hot’s Dewhurst run when Anthony Van Dyck finished 3rd beaten 4 lengths. It’s always dangerous to compare the distance of beaten horses, but that shows Line Of Duty clearly has the ability to be seriously involved at the business end here.
Three unexposed runners look to spring a surprise, something that will require exponential improvement from them all considering the quality of the field. 8 of 10 of the last winners of this race had had a run in at least Listed company before their victory on the Knavesmire. The other two, Wings Of Desire (2016) and Carlton House (2011) provide grounds for hope however, with both having had only two runs prior to their appearance in this race. Carlton House had won a Newbury maiden, while all the more remarkably Wings Of Desire’s victory came on the back of a Wolverhampton maiden win only three weeks prior to the Dante. That is the sort of thing that will be music to the ears of connections of Surfman who scooted up by 14 lengths in a Newcastle novice event two weeks ago. It was pleasing to see him powering ever farther clear up the long Newcastle straight, showing him to have a naturally willing racing attitude. The Kingman colt, a big, long striding type looks to have a bright future and is certainly worth his place in a race of this nature. Odds of about 5/1 generally don’t present much value, however.
Another who deserves a mention is Almania. Sir Michael Stoute does not usually run his horses to make up the numbers, especially so early in their career and it’s likely he will have plotted a path with this one similar to that of Carlton House. He showed a nice attitude on his second start back in August to rally under pressure and win after being headed. Having never run beyond 7 furlongs, his performance in this race will likely decide his future path.
TELECASTER represents Hughie Morrison and last year’s winning jockey Oisin Murphy. Unraced as a 2 year old, he had his first run at the end of March and showed huge promise finishing 2nd to the more experienced Bangkok, a horse that has since gone on the win the Sandown Classic Trial and is available at 16/1 for the Derby. He followed up by routing the field by 9 lengths in his next race at Windsor. Especially taking about that performance was the way that although he had the race in the bag about two furlongs out, when briefly bustled up by Oisin Murphy he responded and quickened again, hitting the line without easing up. While Too Darn Hot and Line Of Duty will both be tough nuts to crack, Telecaster looks an exciting horse to follow and may present some value against the field at around 7/1.
The others Turgenev and Nayef Road look to have it all to do in this sort of company and can likely be discounted.
Grab a trial with our Tipsters
Click the button below to get involved.
Please note that 28 Day Trials are for new customers of that service only. If you’ve had a trial with Architect Tips, you can still grab a trial with The Wizard of Big Odds etc.
Well written . Keep an eye on him.